In the wake of the whistleblower allegations against President Trump, some Republicans have hit the ground defending him with a set of key talking points that, according to the Washington Post‘s Amber Phillips, are easily debunked. She focuses on four main talking points emanating from Republicans in Congress, starting with the claim that there is no “quid pro quo” in the infamous July 25 phone call between Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky — a claim she says is “technically true” but ignores the fact that a quid pro quo is clearly implied during the conversation.
“The context surrounding this call would lead any reasonable person to believe that Trump had things to offer the Ukrainian president if he helped Trump out,” she writes. Of course, there’s the fact that Trump froze military aid to Ukraine days before the call took place. Trump also reportedly dangled a potential White House meeting at Zelensky, which was something the Ukrainian leader wanted for some time.
Then there’s the question of the whistleblower’s credibility, which was backed up in testimony by the acting director of national intelligence, Joseph Maguire, during his testimony before the House Intelligence Committee this Thursday.
“I believe the whistleblower is operating in good faith and has followed the law,” Maguire told Adam Schiff (D-CA).
In regards to the claim that the whistleblower only had second hand knowledge of the call, that, as Phillips points out, is also true. But the key is to “think of the whistleblower as a reporter,” she writes.
In one key instance, we have original source material to back up what the whistleblower has alleged. So far, this person nailed the call between Trump and Zelensky. This person correctly reported nuances about how Trump not only asked about the Bidens, but asked Zelensky for help about other election-related topics.
Strengthening the whistleblower’s account is the fact that he/she talked to numerous U.S. officials while compiling the complaint, which included multiple sources who were “in the room” with the President during the call.
Finally, there’s the narrative that says the allegations against Trump are based on a conspiracy theory disseminated by an anti-Trump media complex. Phillips cites an article from the Washington Examiner that says this exact narrative was given to Republicans by the White House to counter the allegations and to sow distrust in the media.
“The whistleblower does use public events, as reported by journalists, to bolster his or her claims and help paint a picture of a president abusing his power for personal gain. But those news reporters are used to bolster his or her own sources,” Phillips writes, adding that press reports are only part of the story.
“…but they’re not the whistleblower’s only story. In addition, broadly speaking, the reporting by The Washington Post and other outlets on the contents of this complaint have proved to be accurate.”
Featured image via Shutterstock
Donald Trump is the 21st-century Jefferson Davis– and history will judge him
On Friday, Donald Trump and his wife Melania attended an early Independence Day celebration held at Mount Rushmore.
This article first appeared on Salon.
There were fireworks, a military flyover, and "patriotic" songs such as "The Star-Spangled Banner".
The entire spectacle embodied the worst kind of superficial juvenile patriotism.
More than 130,000 Americans are dead from the coronavirus pandemic. The country teeters on the edge of a second Great Depression. A neofascist regime rules in Washington. Donald Trump is in thrall to Vladimir Putin and Russia and in doing so actively betrays the United States and the American people.
‘We will not be silenced’: Trump accuses racial justice protesters of trying to wipe out ‘our’ history at Mount Rushmore
US President Donald Trump bemoaned protests demanding racial justice as "violent mayhem" Friday, but said little about an alarming resurgence of coronavirus cases as he attended a crowded, fireworks-studded Independence Day celebration beneath majestic Mount Rushmore.
Trump, under fire for his response to America's spiraling coronavirus caseload four months before the presidential election, spoke on the eve of the July 4th celebrations before thousands of closely-packed people -- many of whom chanted "Four more years;" few of whom were wearing masks.
In the shadow of four notable predecessors -- George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Theodore Roosevelt and Abraham Lincoln, whose likenesses are carved into a granite cliff in South Dakota's Black Hills -- the president called on supporters to defend America's "integrity".
Trump’s message is still ‘white power’: NYT’s Michelle Goldberg
With so many polls showing President Donald Trump trailing former Vice President Joe Biden, some conservative pundits have been asserting that he needs a stronger message. But liberal New York Times columnist Michelle Goldberg argues that Trump still has a consistent message: racism.
“Trump does indeed have a reelection message, a stark and obvious one," writes Goldberg, a frequent guest on MSNBC. “It is ‘white power.’”
Racism, Goldberg stresses, is something that Trump inevitably turns to when he wants to rally his base.