Quantcast
Connect with us

Trump’s sputtering defense team appears to be spectacularly unprepared for impeachment trial

Published

on

- Commentary

A new book by Pulitzer-winning reporters Philip Rucker and Carol Leonnig, “A Very Stable Genius,” hit the bestseller lists this week. It reports a scene in which President Trump participated in a documentary about the U.S. Constitution in which various well-known people were asked to read their favorite part. Trump chose the opening of Article II, which delineates the power of the president.

ADVERTISEMENT

This article was originally published at Salon

According to Rucker and Leonnig’s account, Trump had a great deal of trouble reading it and got testy, blaming everyone but himself for the problem. At one point he said, “It’s very hard to do because of the language here, it’s very hard to get through that whole thing without a stumble. It’s like a different language, right?”

This is the opening of Article II:

The executive power shall be vested in a President of the United States of America. He shall hold his office during the term of four years, and, together with the Vice President, chosen for the same term, be elected, as follows:

I’m not surprised Trump thought the Constitution was in a foreign language. But I didn’t expect that his lawyers would think so too. You can’t come to any different conclusion after the opening of Tuesday’s impeachment trial.

ADVERTISEMENT

Perhaps Majority Leader Mitch McConnell forgot to tell Trump’s defense team that Senate rules allowed Democrats to offer amendments to the proposed trial rules, but that’s doubtful. They may not have realized that House Intelligence chair Adam Schiff and his team would show up fully prepared to begin laying out their case within those proposed amendments.

The Trump team mainly got up and sputtered about fairness and process and otherwise whined and complained about the House Democrats. They fulfilled their principal duty, which was to provide Fox News with digestible clips of them passing on familiar lies, such as the tiresome falsehood that House Republicans had been shut out of depositions and that the president wasn’t allowed to participate in the House hearings.

White House counsel Pat Cipollone is either a very dishonest lawyer or he has some kind of memory problem:

ADVERTISEMENT

Until yesterday, Cipollone was something of a mystery. Most people hadn’t heard him speak but having been a partner in a big law firm and a long-time Washington figure in Catholic activist circles, I think it was assumed he was a serious person. Tuesday’s long day put an end to that assumption. He was testy and snide though most of it, and failed to offer any cogent legal arguments.

Many of us had thought his incomprehensible screeds like the one above must have been personally dictated by the president. But after watching Cipollone for 11 hours, it’s clear that he is personally very much on Trump’s wavelength in a way that goes beyond the zealous representation of a good lawyer. Let’s just say that he’s got a second career on talk radio or Fox News ahead of him if he wants it.

ADVERTISEMENT

Jay Sekulow, one of Trump’s personal lawyers, was exactly as one might have expected. He was bombastic and flamboyant, just as he’s often been in his career as a right-wing media star and legal representative for the Christian right. He managed to have the single most embarrassing moment of the entire day when he took to the podium to rave about House manager Val Demings’ supposed claims of “lawyer lawsuits.” Sekulow declared:

And by the way — lawyer lawsuits? Lawyer lawsuits? We’re talking about the impeachment of a president of the United States, duly elected, and the members — the managers are complaining about lawyer lawsuits? The Constitution allows lawyer lawsuits. It’s disrespecting the Constitution of the United States to even say that in this Chamber — lawyer lawsuits. It’s a dangerous moment for America when an impeachment of a president of the United States is being rushed through because of lawyer lawsuits. The Constitution allows it, if necessary. The Constitution demands it, if necessary.

The problem is that Demings never said anything about “lawyer lawsuits” and nobody knew what in the world Sekulow was ranting about. Demings had said that “FOIA lawsuits filed by third parties cannot serve as a credible alternative to congressional oversight.”

ADVERTISEMENT

In true Trumpian fashion, the White House actually doubled down on their error:

No, the transcript does not say that. The video of Demings’ comments is clear. In any case, no one has been able to explain Sekulow’s unhinged reaction to “lawyer lawsuits” or “FOIA lawsuits.” It was surreal.

The Trump team showed up with the intention of doing nothing but complain about Democratic amendments. Unfortunately for them, the House managers outmaneuvered them.

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell had dropped a big bomb late Monday. First he said he would follow the Clinton impeachment procedures of opening statements, then questions from senators, and then an up-or-down vote on whether to consider calling witnesses or new evidence. He also planned to give each side 24 hours to make their case — but unlike the Clinton trial in which they could take as many days as necessary, he wanted them to complete their cases in two 12-hour days each. Instead of allowing the evidence from the House impeachment hearings to be automatically entered into evidence he wanted that to be considered after the trial was completed as well.

ADVERTISEMENT

It was a daft proposal and on Tuesday McConnell amended these rules slightly at the last minute, allowing three days for each side at trial and entering the existing evidence into the record automatically. (The news went forth that “moderate” Sen. Susan Collins and some other Republicans demanded the change but you can’t help but suspect that McConnell and Collins cooked this together in advance to make her look good.)

McConnell is still insisting on leaving the question of witnesses until the end of the trial which makes no sense in a case where the president has stonewalled the whole process. That’s what led Minority Leader Chuck Schumer to offer 11 different amendments asking for witnesses and documents to McConnell’s resolution, a process that ended up taking 11 hours, with arguments on both sides.

Starting the day not knowing if they were going to have time to make their case or have their evidence put into the record, the Democratic managers decided not to make long legal or constitutional arguments. They instead used the time allotted by the Senate rules for amendments to put on their case, show their evidence and argue that the witnesses and documents the White House refuses to provide prove that it’s engaged in a cover-up.

They were extremely well prepared, with each manager handling different aspects of the case with exhibits and well thought-out arguments for each one. The Trump team’s members were like kids claiming that the dog ate their homework. They obviously thought the day would to be a political sparring match and instead found themselves deep in the evidence without much to rebut it, except Trump’s Twitter feed and Sean Hannity’s talking points.

ADVERTISEMENT

Nonetheless, the Senate voted down every amendment on party-line votes, as expected. The fix was in from the start. But if this trial is a competition for the hearts and minds of the American people, the Trump team lost the first round. And you only get one chance to make a first impression.


Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Critics of sweeping policy changes always make one huge mistake: Robert Reich

Published

on

In last Wednesday night’s Democratic debate, former South Bend mayor Pete Buttigieg charged that Senator Bernie Sanders’ policy proposals would cost $50 trillion. Holy Indiana.

Larry Summers, formerly chief White House economic advisor for Barack Obama, puts the price tag at $60 trillion. “We are in a kind of new era of radical proposal,” he told CNN.

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

By any means necessary: Trump’s prepared to cheat again in 2020 — and lie about it shamelessly

Published

on

The presidential campaign is heating up and Democratic voters are wringing their hands trying to figure out which of their candidates is more likely to beat President Trump. Pundits have talked themselves in circles while strategists try to figure out which demographic mixture and turnout models will lead to victory as the number-crunchers slice and dice the polls to discover the most likely path to 270 votes in the Electoral College.

This isn't unusual but it is especially intense this time because most Democrats understand that Donald Trump is an existential crisis. Because of the nature of his implausible victory in 2016 and the surreal character of the last three years, they have lost confidence in their ability to understand politics at all.

Continue Reading
 

Breaking Banner

The religious mourning of ‘Saint’ Kobe Bryant with Staples Center memorial

Published

on

This morning, the 24th of February, tens of thousands of fans are set to gather at LA's Staples Center to mourn the passing of all-time NBA great Kobe Bryant who, along with his daughter Gianna Bryant and seven others, died tragically in a helicopter crash on the 26th of January.

This is, in fact, the official version of a spontaneous response that took place just days after Bryant’s untimely death, when thousands of fans gathered at the Staples Center to pay homage to the 18-time all-star. Flowers, photos, and candles were transported immediately by fans wearing Kobe’s jersey to create a memorialized space and share in the tragedy. Around the league, NBA games held moments of silence to recognize Kobe’s contribution to the sport, while individual players found ways to honor Bryant’s legacy. Some took symbolic penalties like a 24-second shot clock violation (Kobe wore number 24 for a significant portion of his career) while others broke down on the bench. Tributes emerged online as well as globally, including a court-sized mural depicting Bryant and his daughter in the Philippines. A man in North Carolina even made a custom casket in honor of Bryant that’s currently on display at the Staples Center.

Continue Reading
 
 
close-image