Quantcast
Connect with us

Trump ignored White House economists’ warning of devastating impact of pandemic months ago: report

Published

on

Steve Mnuchin and Donald Trump (Mandel Ngan:AFP)
White House economists released a study last year that warned a pandemic could kill 500,000 people and devastate the economy months before the coronavirus outbreak, but top officials and the president appear to have ignored their warning.

A study by the Council of Economic Advisers ordered by the National Security Council predicted that a pandemic similar to the 1918 Spanish flu or the 2009 swine flu could lead to a half-million deaths and cost the economy as much as $3.8 trillion.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Tens of millions of people could become ill, with many requiring hospitalization; and a significant number—especially among the vulnerable elderly population—could die,” the study said.

“People may conflate the high expected costs of pandemic flu with the far more common, lower-cost seasonal flu,” the authors wrote. “It is not surprising that people might underappreciate the economic and health risks posed by pandemic flu and not invest in ways to reduce these risks.”

But the study “went unheeded inside the administration,” The New York Times reported.

Advertisement:

Tomas Philipson, the acting chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers, insisted months later in February that public health threats usually do not impact the economy and argued that the coronavirus would not be as bad as the annual flu.

“I don’t think corona is as big a threat as people make it out to be,” he said, according to The Times. “If you look at the resilience of the economy to a public health threat, certainly we have much bigger threats than the coronavirus.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Trump, who claims to understand the economy “better than anybody,” similarly sought to downplay the risk posed by the virus in an effort to stop the ongoing stock market slide.

The president argued that the market collapse had little to do with the coronavirus and declared that “life & the economy go on” as the death toll in the U.S. rose in early March.

Trump later declared that restrictions to contain the virus were worse than the virus itself and called to “reopen” the economy by Easter, though he backed off that threat earlier this week after the White House projected that 1.5 million to more than 2 million people would die without sustained mitigation efforts.

ADVERTISEMENT

Researchers at the University of Chicago found that the restrictions, while causing skyrocketing unemployment and stock market collapse, would actually save the economy $8 trillion compared to the alternative — rampant death.

Anna Scherbina, one of the authors of the White House study, who has since left the administration, rejected the view that the restrictions hurt more than the impact of the virus itself.

ADVERTISEMENT

She told The Times that she estimates mitigation efforts would cost the economy about $36 billion per week, but the alternative would cost the economy about $13 trillion.

The economic study is one of numerous warnings which Trump and his administration appeared to have ignored before the coronavirus hit. The number of cases increased rapidly and quickly surpassed those in the much more heavily populated China, where the outbreak began. The number of deaths has since eclipsed the death toll from the 9/11 terrorist attacks.

Like the White House, the Department of Health and Human Services spent months simulating a potential respiratory virus pandemic originating in China for much of last year. The agency determined that such a pandemic would kill 568,000 people. The study provided recommendations to resolve the country’s lack of preparedness for a pandemic scenario, but its advice was similarly ignored, The New York Times reported.

ADVERTISEMENT

As infections grew in China, intelligence agencies issued classified warnings in January and February about the threat posed by the virus. Those warnings also appear to have been ignored by both Trump and congressional lawmakers, The Washington Post reported.

After ignoring the warnings, the Trump administration reportedly failed to consult the National Security Council’s pandemic playbook created to deal with such a crisis and federal agencies bungled early attempts to roll out testing, leaving the country in the dark as the virus spread in numerous states.

After ignoring the repeated warning signs and seeking to downplay the threat, Trump has more recently claimed that “nobody knew there would be a pandemic or epidemic of this proportion.”

“It’s an unforeseen problem,” he said. “What a problem. Came out of nowhere.”

ADVERTISEMENT

But one federal official with access to the intelligence reports rejected Trump’s claim, telling The Post that agencies “have been warning on this since January.”

“Donald Trump may not have been expecting this, but a lot of other people in the government were — they just couldn’t get him to do anything about it,” the official said. “The system was blinking red.”


Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

2020 Election

Trump makes his closing pitch to ‘suburban housewives’ at rally: ‘Women, I like women — I like women!’

Published

on

President Donald J. Trump made his closing pitch to who he called "suburban housewives" at his Arizona rally Monday. He bellowed, "Women, I like women -- I like women!" in a classic Trumpian move while his supporters cheered.

"Listen, here's the story. They said 'suburban women' -- I used to call them 'suburban housewives,' I got killed all the time. I said, 'ugh, I better go politically correct.' Is there one woman here who minds being called, if you're married at least, a 'suburban housewife' 'cause..."

The crowd erupted with "No!"

"The only ones who mind are those characters... there's a lot of people up there - the press, right? Those are the only ones. The rest of them don't."

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

‘Backing out again?’: Trump ridiculed for trying to ‘wimp’ out of debate with whiny letter about the topics

Published

on

President Donald Trump's campaign manager Bill Stepien sent a long, rambling letter to the Presidential Debate Commission attacking them for being all-in for Vice President Joe Biden and demanding that they change the debate topics.

Moderator Kristen Welker said that the topics they intend to discuss will be fighting the COVID-19 pandemic, issues facing American families, race in America, climate change, national security and leadership in general. Stepien complained that "national security" or "leadership" doesn't have enough to do with foreign policy as he would prefer.

Continue Reading
 

Breaking Banner

Trump says he could raise $1 billion in a single day — he just doesn’t want to

Published

on

Speaking at a rally in Prescott, Arizona, this Monday, President Trump gave an excuse as to why he's not matching Joe Biden when it comes to fundraising, saying that he'd be "the greatest fundraiser in history" -- all he'd have to do it call up every Wall Street firm and major company in the U.S.

"I would take in more money, but you know what? I don't want to do that, because if I do that I'm totally compromised -- because when they call me, you know, you're a loyal person and what happens, is, hey -- you'll do things..." Trump said.

Watch the video below:

Continue Reading
 
 
Democracy is in peril. Invest in progressive news. Join Raw Story Investigates for $1. Go ad-free. LEARN MORE