Justice Sam Alito faced criticism on Wednesday for refusing to recuse himself from a Colorado climate case involving oil companies despite significant conflicts of interest.
Slate writer Hannah Story Brown highlighted Alito's oil industry stock holdings and his personal relationship with billionaire Paul Singer, whose hedge fund Elliott Investment Management holds major investments in Suncor, one of the defendant companies.
The relationship drew scrutiny in 2023 when ProPublica reported Alito failed to disclose a free private jet trip worth over $100,000 each way to Alaska arranged by Singer. Alito explained the seat would have gone unused and characterized it as saving taxpayer money.
Brown criticized the Supreme Court's lack of binding ethics code, noting federal employees face strict gift restrictions while justices with lifetime appointments can avoid disclosure requirements. She argued the Court has become less transparent, increasingly using the shadow docket for major decisions outside official proceedings.
Watch the video below.
