For nearly a decade, Americans have been forced to confront a question its founders could scarcely have imagined: What happens when the safeguards designed to protect the republic prove pathetically insufficient to restrain a president determined to not only test their limits, but to obliterate them?
The answer has exposed vulnerabilities that no serious democracy can afford to ignore.
As Democrats prepare to take control of both chambers of Congress, the debate over investigations, impeachment and accountability will inevitably dominate Washington. But beyond those immediate battles lies a more consequential question: One for the long game. What do we do the next time this happens?
If you think the end of Trump means the end of fascist, white nationalist candidates, think again. The MAGA movement has lifted a rock that will take generations to put back in place, exposing a dark underbelly of American extremism and emboldening a new generation of fearmongers, hate merchants and violent extremists who no longer feel compelled to hide in the shadows.
So, what happens when the next power-hungry, lunatic president decides that constitutional restraints are merely inconveniences, congressional oversight is optional, and decades of international agreements can be discarded on a whim?
Will Americans once again spend the next decade held hostage by a president who operates above the law, waiting years for elections to offer the only hope of rescue, all while the damage to our democracy grows exponentially?
Or will this Democratic-controlled Congress finally heed the lessons of the past decade and recognize that, however well-intentioned our Founding Fathers may have been, they could never have envisioned a political movement so thoroughly consumed by blind allegiance to a would-be despot that half of Congress would willingly abandon its constitutional oaths in service to one dangerous man? Will lawmakers finally establish enforceable safeguards that prevent future presidents from holding the nation hostage for years while our democratic institutions crumble around them? And what would those safeguards look like?
That question should be at the center of the next legislative debate. One thing is for certain: A democracy cannot depend on presidential restraint any longer.
The American constitutional system was designed around checks and balances. Expecting everyone to agree to play by the rules. Assuming public officials will respect institutional boundaries, comply with lawful orders and recognize limits on their authority.
The presidency of Donald Trump has eviscerated that assumption and shone a white-hot spotlight on what happens when those expectations fail.
Congressional subpoenas can be challenged — or, depending on the mood of our attorney general, ignored completely. Litigation can take years. Executive orders can reshape federal policy before courts determine their legality. And those courts could be stacked with appointees willing to do the bidding of the man who appointed them. And impeachment? Please. The Constitution's principal mechanism for removing a president accused of serious misconduct not only requires a two-thirds Senate vote for conviction, but it has zero criminal implications.
The Supreme Court's presidential immunity decision further decimated the possibility of accountability by granting absolute immunity for presidential acts and presumptive immunity for other official acts.
The ruling did not place every presidential action beyond legal scrutiny. But it raised difficult questions about the reach of criminal accountability.
The larger problem is that accountability delayed can become accountability denied. And that lack of consequence translates well beyond our own backyard.
Do we expect our allies to just keep "forgiving" us for ripping up treaties, starting illegal wars, siding with autocrats, and burning bridges that took decades to build every four years as a matter of policy? That’s ludicrous.
For the past century, our allies have operated with the expectation that American institutions provided a meaningful degree of continuity. Thanks to Donald Trump and the modern-day Republican Party, that expectation is completely out the window.
Why should another government risk its national security on promises that might be abandoned tomorrow, without the guarantee of meaningful congressional involvement?
Restoring confidence requires more than reassuring speeches from a new president. It requires institutions capable of providing continuity and implementing swift action when that continuity is threatened. Given our current situation, the likelihood of stopping the next out-of-control president before he starts is about as likely as Silicon Valley putting humanity over profit.
Obviously, Congress can’t just dismiss a president whenever it disapproves of his/her decisions. Thus, any proposal for a faster removal mechanism would most likely require a constitutional amendment. Because, as we have seen, a system that relies exclusively on voters to correct abuses every four years allows for substantial damage to be done in the meantime.
America's allies need evidence that its commitments can endure beyond one individual. Americans need confidence that constitutional limits are more than polite suggestions.
And future generations deserve institutions that do not require years of national, as well as global, crisis before responding to presidential abuses. It’s the political equivalent of watching your house burn, but not being able to call the fire department for four years. And, if that’s the case, exactly how much of your house will be left?
Report typos and corrections to corrections@rawstory.com.
For customer support contact support@rawstory.com.
Should Howard Lutnick be investigated for his ties to the Nvidia scandal?
VOTE NOW



