Quantcast
Connect with us

Consumer Reports: Most medical implants never tested for safety

Published

on

The majority of medical devices implanted into patients’ bodies have never been tested by the FDA, according to a stunning report from the consumer advocacy magazine Consumer Reports.

The report stated that while tens of millions of Americans live with some form of medical implant in their body, few of these devices are subjected to rigorous testing. Under current FDA policy, medical device manufacturers are able to “grandfather in” new devices if they are “substantially equivalent” to a device that is already in use.

ADVERTISEMENT

Rita Redberg, M.D., a professor of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco, said that this sets up an ironic paradox. “The paradox is that companies go to the FDA and claim that a device is ‘substantially equivalent,’ but when they market it, they claim it’s ‘new and better.’”

Such has been the case with surgical transvaginal mesh of the kind that was used to restructure the pelvis and bladder of 54-year-old Janet Holt of Floresville, Texas, one of the three victims of faulty medical devices whose stories are detailed in Consumer Reports. Hold was told by her gynecologist that a procedure involving surgical mesh would reverse her bladder and uterine prolapse.

Once it was inside her body, the mesh shrank and shifted. Holt was in so much pain she couldn’t stand, sit or walk. Then the mesh began to protrude through her vaginal wall, a sensation she likened to “open cigarette burns with each step you take. It’s complete torture.”

Five years and eight corrective surgeries later, Holt continues to struggle with after-effects of the faulty mesh, which is still on the market in spite of thousands of complaints. The synthetic mesh was never tested on humans, but made it through the approval process because it was “substantially equivalent” to a type of mesh used since the 1950s for abdominal hernia repair, but never tested for pelvic or uterine restructuring.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Lap-Band gastric band marketed by the company Allergan was also rushed to market without adequate testing, but by a different route. The bands were different enough from any previous devices that they couldn’t be grandfathered in, but the testing protocols for surgical devices aren’t nearly as rigorous as the requirements for new drugs.

To even apply for testing for a new drug, the FDA charges $1.84 million. — but the FDA only requires $220,050 to test a new device. The single test study for Allergan’s Lap-Band only consisted of 299 patients over a three year period. Around 51 percent of those people experienced nausea and vomiting and a full quarter of the patients had the gastric bands removed because of complications or failure to lose weight.

Lisa Wilson, who was 46 in 2009 when she received her Lap-Band, didn’t have access to any of those data while making her decision to undergo surgery. The implanted band constricts the stomach, making it unable to hold large amounts of food.

ADVERTISEMENT

Wilson said that for her, the problems began immediately. She couldn’t keep down even small amounts of food and was vomiting every day. As time wore on, the side effects of the band became more intense and in December 2010, it became clear that the band was cutting into the lining of her stomach and should be removed immediately. Wilson developed a post-surgical infection that left her with a collapsed lung.

John Santa, M.D., of the Consumer Reports Health Ratings Center asks how consumers would respond to a vehicle with a recall rate commensurate to the Lap-Band’s 51 percent of complications and 25 percent outright failure of the device to perform as promised. “Consumers and regulators would be up in arms. But in the world of medical devices, these things often stay hidden.”

Dr. Stephen Tower of Alaska was a victim of a device that he himself had implanted into patients. The DuPuy ASR XL was all-metal hip replacement, supposedly advantageous over metal-and-plastic hips because it was often the plastic socket that wore out first on older models of artificial hip.

ADVERTISEMENT

Initially upon receiving his new hip, Dr. Tower was overjoyed. He was able to return to athletic pursuits that he had enjoyed before arthritis in his hip had made them impossible. A year after his operation, however, things were not going well.

The doctor was in constant pain and his blood was showing elevated levels of the metals used to fashion the artificial ball and socket of the hip joint, a sign that the device was deteriorating. Then he started noticing other problems such as “disturbed sleep, mood swings and anxiety, hearing loss, visual problems, and tinnitus.”

DePuy engineers insisted that they’d never seen anything like Tower’s case, but his research, some of which has since been published in medical journals was turning up case after case of “profound poisoning” caused by debris from the implants turning up in patients’ blood. Tower has had his hip re-replaced and his symptoms have since eased.

ADVERTISEMENT

The DePuy hip was recalled, but not before thousands of patients had received them.

In 2011, the Institute of Medicine convened a panel that ruled that the current FDA review process for medical devices is inadequate. Consumers Union, the advocacy arm of Consumer Reports, agrees with the Institute of Medicine and has specific recommendations on how to make them safer, as well as guidelines for how patients can protect themselves against risks.

Below is a two-part CBS report about the Consumer Reports study, as well as information about the defective DePuy ASR XL artificial hips. The segments originally aired Wednesday, March 28:

Part One

ADVERTISEMENT

Part Two


Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Trump unravels over Ukraine call in extensive thread– then blames Democrats

Published

on

President Donald Trump continued to unravel over the call he had with Ukraine on July 25.

"This Scam going on right now by the Democrats against the Republican Party, and me, was all about a perfect phone call I had with the Ukrainian President. He’s already stated, NO PRESSURE! Where is the Whistleblower, or the 2nd Whistleblower, or the “informant?” All gone because their so-called story didn’t come even close to matching up with the exact transcript of the phone call. Was it a Corrupt Adam Schiff con? Why didn’t the IG see this? When do we depose Shifty Schiff to find out why he fraudulently made up my phone call and read this fiction to Congress and the American People? I demand his deposition. He is a fraud, just like the Russia Hoax was, and the Ukraine Hoax is now. When do the Do Nothing Democrats pay a price for what they are doing to our Country, & when do the Republicans finally fight back?"

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Trump lashes out at Pelosi for going to Jordan to fix his Syria flub

Published

on

Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Donald Trump

President Donald Trump tweeted his anger about Speaker Nancey Pelosi (D-CA) taking a delegation of leaders to Jordan to meet with those working on Syria.

"Pelosi is now leading a delegation of 9, including Corrupt Adam Schiff, to Jordan to check out Syria. She should find out why Obama drew The Red Line In the Sand, & then did NOTHING, losing Syria & all respect. I did something, 58 missiles. One million died under Obama’s mistake!" Trump tweeted Sunday.

https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/1186016354572353536

Vice President Mike Pence went to Turkey last week to attempt to negotiate a ceasefire, but what he ended up with was 120-hour freeze on bombing Kurds.

Continue Reading
 

Breaking Banner

Hillary Clinton posts fake letter from JFK to mock Trump’s absurd one to Turkey

Published

on

Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton has taken up a new hobby of trolling President Donald Trump on Twitter.

The grandmother of three excelled in her sarcasm and stepped up her shade Sunday afternoon by releasing a fake letter from Former President John F. Kennedy to former Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev.

Read the fake letter and see the tweet below:

Dear Premier Khrushchev,

Don't be a d*ck, ok? Get your missiles out of Cuba. Everybody will say 'Yay! Khrushchev! You're the best!' But if you don't everybody will be like 'what an assh*le' and call your garbage country 'The Soviet Bunion.'

Continue Reading
 
 
Help Raw Story Uncover Injustice. Join Raw Story Investigates for $1 and go ad-free.
close-image