Connect with us

Should racism and sexism be censored from Shakespeare?



Shakespeare’s plays contain anti-Semitism, racism and sexism, sexual abuse and violence; they magnify the tenor of their age. But should they be censored when they might offend a particular community today?

Actor Mark Rylance, former Artistic Director of the Globe theatre, recently said that he has sometimes cut “some unfortunate anti-Semitic things” from Shakespeare’s plays:


If a character says it, it doesn’t mean the author means it but since the Holocaust … These statements have a lot more resonance now than they did at that time.

The Merchant of Venice is the most obvious example here. It’s the play that most thoroughly reveals the anti-Semitism of Shakespeare’s day. Rylance’s words perhaps act as a kind of warning to theatremakers in our current climate of fear, heightened by the attack on a kosher supermarket in Paris following the shootings at Charlie Hebdo magazine in January.

Yet for other contemporary writers and directors, Shakespeare’s anti-Semitism offers a chance to highlight social injustice. Director Rupert Goold’s recently revived Merchant of Venice for the Almeida Theatre in London was a bright, brash show that set the play in Las Vegas. It turned the spotlight on the hypocrisy of Christian fundamentalism in a digital age.

Ian McDiarmid as Shylock in the Goold production.
Ellie Kurttz

The anti-Semitism of Shakespeare’s words was emphasised in one shocking scene where, following Shylock’s forced conversion from Judaism to Christianity, Bassanio’s men spit on him and film his humiliation on their mobile phones. He struggles to his feet and runs through the audience, implicitly damning all silent observers with his pained cries. On stage, Bassanio’s men laugh; to them anti-Semitism is no more than a moment’s entertainment. The implication is of course that soon their videos will find an airing on the internet.

It was deeply disturbing: a reminder of how anti-Semitism is alive in the heartland of kitsch and capitalist America. Reviewers called the show “revelatory” and “provocative”; two comments that support productions that don’t shy away from problematic subject matter in difficult times.


But my brief canvas of the audience after the show revealed opinion was divided. Some agreed with the reviews; others felt Goold’s production was irresponsibly extreme, guilty of expressing the racism it purportedly critiqued.

Next year sees the publication of A Wilderness of Monkeys, Howard Jacbson’s literary re-imagining of Merchant. Writing post-Holocaust gives him the chance to exploit the ambivalence in Shakespeare’s text. “Who is the hero of this play and who is the villain?” Jacobson said when the book was announced:

For an English novelist, Shakespeare is where it all begins. For an English novelist who also happens to be Jewish, The Merchant of Venice is where it all snarls up.


An Austrian production of The Merchant of Venice.
Dietmar Stiplovsek/EPA

This does not only apply to English and Jewish authors. Across the world, Syrian writer-director Nawar Bulbul is currently producing Shakespeare with Syrian refugee children in Amman, Jordan. “I would not do Merchant of Venice”, he says. “For me to do that play would be taken as too controversial” (because of Syria’s majority Muslim affiliation).

Conversely, in 2012 leading British actors and directors (including Rylance) signed an open letter calling for the Jewish-Israeli Habima theatre production of Merchant of Venice to be barred from coming to the Globe theatre’s World Shakespeare Festival in London. They complained because of the company’s “shameful record” of performing plays in illegal Israeli settlements in Palestinian territories.


Jacobson responded by writing in the Observer that art “proceeds from, and addresses, our unaligned humanity … So to censor it in the name of political or religious conviction … is to tear out its very heart.” In the end the Habima production took place. Around 15 people were lead from the auditorium during the production for unfurling Palestinian flags.

With the complex contemporary politics this play throws into relief, Shakespeare has left directors and producers a thorny problem. Evidence from his other works suggests he was for free speech however, urging at the end of King Lear that we should “speak what we feel, not what we ought to say”. So perhaps he might have agreed with Jacobson rather than Rylance; as he advocated against censorship of any point of view, even if it might offend or oppose. In Richard II he writes:

Free speech and fearless, I to thee allow.


The ConversationBy Preti Taneja, Queen Mary University of London

This article was originally published on The Conversation.
Read the original article.

Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Trump calls Minneapolis protesters ‘thugs’ — and threatens military action



President Donald Trump blasted protesters in Minnesota outraged over the killing of George Floyd.

“ I can’t stand back & watch this happen to a great American City, Minneapolis,” Trump tweeted after midnight.

“A total lack of leadership. Either the very weak Radical Left Mayor, Jacob Frey, get his act together and bring the City under control, or I will send in the National Guard & get the job done right,” he wrote, even though the National Guard was already deployed.

“ These THUGS are dishonoring the memory of George Floyd, and I won’t let that happen. Just spoke to Governor Tim Walz and told him that the Military is with him all the way. Any difficulty and we will assume control but, when the looting starts, the shooting starts,” he threatened.

Continue Reading

2020 Election

Trump loyalist Lindsey Graham locked in dead heat with Democratic challenger in red South Carolina



Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., is locked in a dead heat in his bid to win re-election, a new online poll finds.

Graham, who has represented South Carolina in Congress since 1995 and held his Senate seat since 2003, has in recent months faced mounting pressure from Democratic challenger Jaime Harrison. A new Civiqs poll released this week finds the two rivals tied at 42%.

A deeper dive into the poll reveals more possibly unnerving developments for Graham. Fifty-six percent of South Carolina voters have an unfavorable view of the senator, while only 35% have a positive view of him.

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

WATCH: Minneapolis police station burns after protesters reportedly seize the building



On Thursday night, the Minneapolis Police Department's third precinct was destroyed.

Here are some of the images from the scene.








Continue Reading
You need honest news coverage. Help us deliver it. Join Raw Story Investigates for $1. Go ad-free.