Quantcast
Connect with us

The myth of Ronald Reagan: Pragmatic moderate or radical conservative?

Published

on

Republican candidates and even Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton have been quoting the 40th president lately but his legacy is filled with complexities

There was a time when he was too radical for Republicans and too polarising for Democrats but these days everyone seems to love Ronald.

The 15 Republican presidential candidates took turns channeling Reagan’s spirit in this week’s debate at the Reagan Library, invoking his name 45 times, by one count .

ADVERTISEMENT

The CNN moderator, Jake Tapper, framed the event as a contest to seize the mantle of the United States’s 40th president. “Ronald Reagan looming large over this debate. So how Reaganesque exactly are these Republicans? We will find out next.”

For the GOP, Reagan is not just a name but an adjective connoting virtue and conservative ideological purity.

Yet Democrats are getting in on the act, too. Hillary Clinton is using Reagan quotes to assail GOP contenders and to bolster progressive policies in her own White House run. And President Barack Obama cites Reagan when promoting his administration’s deal with Iran, noting that the Gipper negotiated with the Soviet Union.

Would the real Ronald Reagan please stand up? Was he a government-shrinking, undocumented immigrant-bashing, climate change-denying, abortion-curbing political granddaddy of today’s Republican presidential hopefuls? Or a liberal peacenik who could moonlight as a Democrat?

ADVERTISEMENT

It is easy to forget that Republicans deemed the California governor too right-wing when he lost the 1976 primary race to President Gerald Ford. And that once in the White House, Democrats assailed him as callous and reckless, and a deceitful architect of the Iran-Contra scandal.

Now, almost three decades after he left office, and 11 years since his death, a president hailed for his commitment to principle appears made of Plasticine, a malleable figure squished into multiple shapes.

One reason is his popularity. Some 90% of Republicans and 60% of Americans have a positive view of Reagan, giving would-be successors incentive to bask in the glow.

ADVERTISEMENT

The other reason is that Reagan was a complex, nuanced figure. He spoke of giving voters “a cause to believe in… raising a banner of no pale pastels, but bold colours”. He was serious about curbing government even while joking about it: “The nine most terrifying words in the English language are: ‘I’m from the government and I’m here to help.’”

Yet as governor and president, Reagan often proved moderate and pragmatic. He did that which is now unforgivable in the GOP, a transgression beyond redemption: he compromised.

So on the one hand there was the president who fired 11,000 striking air traffic controllers, gutted mental health funding, slashed taxes and regulations, built up the armed forces and went to Berlin to challenge the Soviet Union to “tear down this wall”. Plenty there for Jeb Bush, Marco Rubio, Carly Fiorina and Scott Walker to admire.

ADVERTISEMENT

He was also a larger-than-life outsider with memorable one-liners who projected authenticity and a desire to shake up Washington, a case study for Donald Trump, who in customary self-aggrandizing manner said Reagan admired him, inverting the notion of homage.

With a California sun setting over the Simi valley outside, and the Gipper’s Air Force One gleaming behind them, the GOP debate hopefuls invoked Reagan like a talisman.

Ohio governor John Kasich said he “actually flew on this plane with Reagan when I was a congressman”. Kentucky senator Rand Paul recalled meeting Reagan as a teenager and considering him a hero for challenging Ford in the 1976 primaries. “It was a big deal because he was the grassroots, running against the establishment.”

ADVERTISEMENT

New Jersey governor Chris Christie recalled casting his first vote for Reagan over Jimmy Carter in 1980, saying, “Boy, am I glad I did it.” South Carolina senator Lindsey Graham advocated a Reaganite policy of “peace through strength”.

They were all silent on other parts of his legacy. Reagan the environmentalist – as governor he protected California’s wilderness from dams and highways and created an air resources board, as president he launched the Montreal Protocol to protect the ozone layer – did not appear.

Nor did Reagan the spender who raised taxes (four to 11 times, depending how you count) and increased the federal workforce by 324,000 people, raised the debt ceiling 18 times and almost tripled the federal debt.

Nor did Reagan the retreater who withdrew from Lebanon after terrorists killed 248 US marines, leaving the country to civil war, or Reagan the negotiator who reached out to the “evil empire”, or the Reagan who signed California’s liberal abortion law, the Brady gun law, collective bargaining for local government workers and amnesty for almost 3 million undocumented people.

ADVERTISEMENT

“If the current Republican candidates want to truly embody his legacy, they must let go of the false caricature and acknowledge Reagan’s complexity as well as his moderation,” Lawrence Korb, who served as assistant defence secretary during Reagan’s administration, wrote in the Los Angeles Times .

Obama has enlisted this lesser-known Gipper in defence of the Iran nuclear deal, telling the New York Times : “You know, I have a lot of differences with Ronald Reagan, but where I completely admire him was his recognition that if you were able to verify an agreement that you would negotiate with the evil empire that was hellbent on our destruction and was a far greater existential threat to us than Iran will ever be [then it would be worth doing].”

Clinton, the Democratic presidential frontrunner, has channeled her own version of Reagan in the form of quotes and dates plastered alongside photos of GOP rivals.

For Walker the union-buster: “Collective bargaining has played a major role in America’s economic miracle.” (September 3, 1981). For Rubio the tax-slayer: “What we’re trying to move against is institutionalized unfairness. We want to see that everyone pays their fair share and no one gets a free ride.” (June 6 1985). For Trump the deporter: “I believe in amnesty for those who have put down roots and who have lived here even though some time back they may have entered illegally.” (October 21 1984).

ADVERTISEMENT

Clinton’s message is that the GOP has moved far to the right and left Reagan, the real Reagan, behind. Appropriating Reagan for her own campaign, however, would be an audacious heist.

What the Hollywood actor-turned political myth would have made of the combustible 2016 White House race is anyone’s guess. He may well have enjoyed the spectacle given that he compared politics to show business. “You have a hell of an opening, you coast for awhile, you have a hell of a closing.”

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News and Media 2015


Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Ukraine blows up key Trump defense: Top officials knew of military aid freeze before it became public

Published

on

Top Ukrainian officials were alerted in early August that $391 million in U.S. military aid had been frozen as President Donald Trump sought to pressure the country to investigate Joe Biden.

That undercuts the president's latest defense arguing that the foreign ally couldn't have felt pressured because Ukraine was not yet aware that the aid had been frozen, reported the New York Times.

Former Ukraine ambassador Bill Taylor told Congress on Tuesday that the freeze was directly related to Trump's demand for an announcement that Biden was under investigation.

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Trump attorney shocks judge by claiming president could shoot somebody on 5th Avenue: ‘Nothing could be done’

Published

on

William Consovoy, an attorney for President Donald Trump, argued in court on Wednesday that President Donald Trump is immune from prosecution if he literally shoots someone on Fifth Avenue.

In a hearing before the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan, Consovoy took the position that Trump is immune from a subpoena for his financial records, which are being investigated by Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance Jr.

At one point, Judge Denny Chin asked Consovoy about what he called the "Fifth Avenue example," referring to a Trump claim that he could shoot someone on Fifth Avenue and get away with it.

Continue Reading
 

Breaking Banner

‘Not a pretty picture’: Second-ranking GOP senator inches closer to impeachment after Bill Taylor testimony

Published

on

The second-ranking Republican senator sounded an alarm over testimony by the former Ukraine ambassador.

GOP Whip John Thune (R-SD) reacted to testimony Tuesday by veteran diplomat Bill Taylor, who told lawmakers that President Donald Trump directed efforts to pressure Ukraine to announce an investigation of Joe Biden in exchange for congressionally approved military aid.

"The picture coming out based on the reporting we’ve seen is not a good one," Thune told reporters Wednesday, "but I would say until we have a process that allows to see this with full transparency it’s pretty hard to come to hard and fast conclusions."

Continue Reading
 
 
Help Raw Story Uncover Injustice. Join Raw Story Investigates for $1 and go ad-free.
close-image