The many stories of Timothy Wiltsey's disappearance
Timothy Wiltsey

NEW BRUNSWICK--The tape wound back the clock 25 years. Former Det. Sgt. Richard Sloan could be heard speaking loudly, in sharp contrast to Michelle Lodzinski's quiet, gentle tone. In a soft, high-pitched girlish voice, she gave a statement to police about what happened on May 25, 1991--the night she claimed her 5-year-old son, Timothy Wiltsey, disappeared…