Quantcast
Connect with us

Twitter hammers scientific journal for article praising ‘the Creator’ for ‘proper design’ of human hands

Published

on

A scientific journal quickly retracted a peer-reviewed scientific paper that credits “the Creator” with designing the human hand — after Twitter users brutally mocked the publication.

The paper was published by the journal PLOS ONE in January, but went largely unnoticed until British researcher James McInerney called the journal “a joke,” reported Science Alert.

McInerney explained that creationism had been annoying him for at least 20 years, and the research paper — titled “Biomechanical characteristics of hand coordination in grasping activities of daily living” — referred repeatedly to a supernatural creator.

Twitter users hammered the journal using the hashtags #HandOfGod and #Creatorgate.

ADVERTISEMENT

The journal retracted the paper two days after the criticism was raised on social media.

The team of researchers from Huazhong University of Science and Technology in Wuhan, China, recruited 30 volunteers to wear special gloves that tracked the movements of their hands as they performed various tasks.

The research team, led by Cai-Hua Xiong, wrote that hand coordination indicated “the mystery of the Creator’s invention,” and reflected the “proper design by the Creator.”

ADVERTISEMENT

“Our study can improve the understanding of the human hand and confirm that the mechanical architecture is the proper design by the Creator for dexterous performance of numerous functions following the evolutionary remodeling of the ancestral hand for millions of years,” the researchers concluded.

The authors blamed a language barrier for their repeated references to a supernatural creator.

“Our study has no relationship with creationism,” explained lead author Ming-Jin Liu. “English is not our native language. Our understanding of the word Creator was not actually as a native English speaker expected. Now we realised that we had misunderstood the word Creator. What we would like to express is that the biomechanical characteristic of tendious connective architecture between muscles and articulations is a proper design by the NATURE (result of evolution) to perform a multitude of daily grasping tasks.”

ADVERTISEMENT

But the incident highlighted what many scientists see as a widespread problem in the editorial and peer-review process — but many cheered PLOS ONE’s relatively quick response to criticism by social media users.

Science took ages to address blog and social media criticisms of incorrect information because they only respond to formal criticisms,” said Jonathan Eisen, chair of PLOS Biology’s advisory board. “PLOS ONE is responding to social media, which most journals pretend doesn’t even exist.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Report typos and corrections to [email protected].

Send confidential news tips to [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

The Robert Mueller standard must be overthrown — for the sake of democracy

Published

on

Special counsel Robert Mueller’s report is a meticulous and compelling document recounting President Donald Trump’s actions and the informational warfare carried out during the 2016 election by the Russian government. But it contains a serious flaw — and it sents a terrible precedent for the country.

We’re now confronted with that flaw once again as the Justice Department has revealed that the case of the 2016 criminal hush money payments meant to benefit Trump’s campaign has closed. Michael Cohen has already been imprisoned for his part in the scheme, but his testimony, public evidence, and common sense all indicate that Trump, too, was just as culpable.

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Rush Limbaugh admits his attacks on Obama were ‘bogus’ as he attempts to defend Trump

Published

on

Conservative radio host Rush Limbaugh admitted that Republican fear-mongering over the federal deficit under President Obama was “bogus,” while defending the deficit's explosive rise to $1 trillion under President Trump.

This article originally appeared at Salon.

During Limbaugh’s show on Tuesday, a caller suggested that Republicans should nominate a young fiscal conservative instead of Trump, citing the rising deficit. Limbaugh dismissed the concerns, declaring that fiscal conservatism was basically a sham all along.

Continue Reading
 

Breaking Banner

George Takei opens up about being held in an internment camp — and his views on Trump

Published

on

At a time when comic books are regularly adapted into superhero movies, George Takei's new graphic memoir "They Called Us Enemy" involves heroes who would also work wonderfully on the silver screen. To be sure, the main characters don't wear colorful costumes or use superpowers, but they are heroes nonetheless — and what they do, in the face of evils no less than those posed by fictional villains, is pretty super too.

This article originally appeared at Salon.

Continue Reading
 
 
 

Copyright © 2019 Raw Story Media, Inc. PO Box 21050, Washington, D.C. 20009 | Masthead | Privacy Policy | For corrections or concerns, please email [email protected]

Join Me. Try Raw Story Investigates for $1. Invest in Journalism. Escape Ads.
close-image