Quantcast
Connect with us

WATCH: 9-year-old girl impersonates Hillary Clinton and critiques her immigration policy

Published

on

Like many 9-year-old girls, Eva spends much of her time watching presidential debates, pondering identity politics, and criticizing Hillary Rodham Clinton through the art of impersonation.

I was introduced to Eva’s political performance art and analysis by her proud aunt, journalist Rania Khalek, who, recorded videos of her niece on her phone, which Eva “insisted” she do.

ADVERTISEMENT

I related immediately to the early political engagement demonstrated by Eva. I kicked off my career as a feminist film critic at the age of five, pointing out the “prejudge against women,” evident in the movies I would watch at home on VHS. Given that I only watched Hollywood versions of musicals (Kiss Me Kate, Bye Bye Birdie, Seven Brides for Seven Brothers) there was a lot to work with. Within a few years, however, I had grown dissatisfied by the bourgeois confines of cultural criticism and the Second wave feminist lens which saw gender in a vacuum and ignored the interplay of gender and race. My intersectional and Marxian framework can be traced back to “Last Night I had a dream,” a critically acclaimed and award-winning first person poem about a homeless woman which I wrote at the age of eight. The work was recognized by my grandmother’s union, the Social Services Employees Union, and printed in their newspaper. I also entered the poem into a contest held by a children’s bookstore. Not surprisingly, they were loath to reward such a radical and disruptive work of art. At the age of ten I decided to switch careers and became a journalist, writing and presenting to my fourth grade social studies class a student report entitled: “Rodney King and police brutality: not just an isolated incident.”

My comrade Eva and I share many criticisms of Hillary Clinton and are both supporters of Bernie Sanders.

Though I’m a Bernie Bro,  I think even a Hillary supporter would find these amusing. They are certainly funnier, more nuanced and more fact-based than the so-called satire going around which is based on the absurd idea that every single thing is Sanders does is motivated by sexism.  OK. I’ll get off my soapbox now. Back to the videos…

Khalek told me:

My entire family has been feeling the Bern, especially my parents. They’re working class immigrants from Lebanon, so hearing a presidential candidate slam people like Henry Kissinger and condemn regime change and defend the humanity of Palestinians was a really big deal for them.
I imagine a lot of Arab-Americans who’ve been following the election can relate. We’re used to politicians talked about us like a diseased predators. Sanders has been a refreshing break from that. Anyway, the point is excitement about Sanders has been a major topic of conversation and sometimes debate at family gatherings and Eva absorbs everything.
The issue that really politicized Eva was, according to Khalek, deporting immigrant children:
It wasn’t until Eva got stuck hanging out with me during a Democratic debate in February that she got really into the race. She wasn’t paying much attention to the sparring until she heard Sanders say that Clinton called for deporting child refugees to send a message to their parents. She was genuinely horrified and has been fixated on the presidential election ever since.
Eva insisted that I record her imitating the candidates. She’s really into theater so she likes to act out mini-plays for us. She recruited her 12-year-old brother Kareem to play Bernie Sanders in a mock debate against her as Hillary Clinton. They planned out a couple of the lines, but most of it was improvised.
Sure enough, the video reveals just how incensed Eva is about Clinton’s callous response to children fleeing the violence. Trigger-warning: this video contains criticism of Clinton that is based on her policies and not her gender and, as such, may be disturbing to viewers who refuse to acknowledge the problematic nature of many of Clinton’s policies, because they are focused on Sanders’ finger-wagging.

This video was recorded over the weekend at a birthday party for a relative. The election came up and Eva, unprompted, expressed her frustrations with the reductive identity-politics based discussion of Clinton, though not in those exact words. She laments the superficial framing which focuses on the candidates’ gender and ignores the differences between the candidates’ policies, many of which effect women directly or indirectly. Eva’s analysis is far more nuanced than many of the “liberal feminists” who frame every single thing that Sanders does as misogynist. Trigger warning: this video contains young girl on younger girl violence.
Now that you’ve seen the other two videos, which show a more nuanced critique, watch this video which displays a more visceral response to Clinton’s policies. Trigger warning: this video contains Lego-based objectification of women. 

As Khalek explains, “What all of this has taught me is that kids are incredible at detecting bulls***, sometimes even better than adults.” My own take-aways are that it’s too bad more people aren’t as woke and intersectional as Eva. And #ImWithEva. And, Eva for president!

Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Trump just lost another effort to try and block Manhattan DA from from getting his financial documents

Published

on

President Donald Trump has lost another case against Manhattan District Attorney Cy Vance, who is seeking the president's financial documents as part of a grand jury case looking into possible bank and tax fraud.

https://twitter.com/neal_katyal/status/1296448357821566976

Trump had fought the subpoenas in court but the judge threw out his complaint Thursday morning, meaning that the case can move forward and that Trump must turn over the financial documents requested.

Last month, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that Trump is not immune from criminal prosecution and that he must comply with subpoenas. Vance had sought records from the accounting firm that Trump uses as well as Deutsche Bank, which has loaned Trump millions over the years.

Continue Reading

2020 Election

Trump aides scrambling to hide his ‘dumpster fire’ poll numbers to keep him from ‘flying into a rage’: report

Published

on

According to a report from the Daily Beast, aides to Donald Trump are doing their best to keep him in the dark about his terrible poll numbers prior to November's election out of fear of his wrath.

With the president's poll numbers plummeting in a match-up with presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden, White House staffers and campaign officials are trying to keep the president calm while at the same time working to turn around a re-election campaign that is floundering.

Continue Reading
 

Breaking Banner

‘I have a son and I want you to meet him’: Anderson Cooper chokes up welcoming his baby to the world

Published

on

CNN anchor Anderson Cooper announced on Thursday that he is now a father.

"It has been a difficult time in all of our lives and there are certainly many hard days ahead. It is, I think, especially important in these times of trouble to try to hold on to moments of joy and moments of happiness," Cooper said. "As we mourn the loss of loved ones, we're also blessed with new life and new love."

"On Monday, I became a father," Cooper revealed. "I am a dad, I have a son, and I want you to meet him.

He introduced Wyatt Morgan Cooper to CNN's viewers.

"He is sweet and soft and healthy and I am beyond happy. As a gay kid, I never thought it would be possible to have a child, and I am so grateful for all those who paved the way and for the doctors and nurses and all those involved in my son's birth."

Continue Reading
 
 
Democracy is in peril. Invest in progressive news. Join Raw Story Investigates for $1. Go ad-free. LEARN MORE