Quantcast
Connect with us

Republican voters are driving out candidates seen as disloyal to Trump — but will they sink the GOP in the process?

Republican voters are driving out candidates seen as disloyal to Trump — will they sink their party in the process? It’s Donald Trump’s Republican Party now — and that’s just how GOP voters like it

Published

on

At the moment the Republican Party’s biggest challenge, strategically speaking, is the fact that its own voters can’t quit President Donald Trump.

“We are in a strange place. It’s almost, it’s becoming a cultish thing, isn’t it? It’s not a good place for any party to end up with a cult-like situation as it relates to a president that happens to be of, purportedly, of the same party,” Sen. Bob Corker, R-Tenn., told NBC News on Wednesday.

While Corker’s comment came in reference to the party’s refusal to consider legislation that would have checked Trump’s ability to implement new tariffs, he could just as easily have been talking about this week’s primary results.

There’s no better example the Republican primary in South Carolina’s 1st congressional district, where incumbent Rep. Mark Sanford was ousted by a challenger who mercilessly attacked him for his anti-Trump apostasy. A few weeks earlier, Rep. Martha Roby suffered a similar (if less dire) fate in Alabama’s 2nd district, where she failed to breach 50 percent of the popular vote and was forced into a runoff with Bobby Bright, a former congressman (and former Democrat) who came at her from the Trumpian far right.

“I will say that Roby may be a better case of this than Sanford because Sanford may have already been a little weak,” said Geoffrey Skelley, media relations coordinator for the University of Virginia Center for Politics and associate editor of Sabato’s Crystal Ball, in an interview with Salon. “In 2016, he won 56 percent of the primary vote, so that may be evidence that he wasn’t that strong to begin with.

“With Roby, you can even see it in the general election result in 2016,” Skelley added. Roby won that race easily, but “there was a big write-in vote, and she didn’t win by as much as you might think in her district. The fact that a former Democrat is her opponent in the runoff there is pretty striking.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I haven’t followed Bright’s campaign closely, but I would assume that he’s running in some degree in support of the president because he couldn’t get in that position otherwise,” Skelley continued. “But if Roby loses to a former Democrat who voted for Nancy Pelosi for speaker of the House, that would be really telling” in terms of Republican voters’ priorities in one of the safest seats in the nation. “Disloyalty to the president,” he added, has become “unforgivable.”

The fact that Republican voters won’t forgive any perceived disloyalty to the Trumpian cause — whether it’s Roby criticizing the future president after the “Access Hollywood” tape dropped during the 2016 campaign, Sanford claiming that Trump had increased hate in America or politicians like Corker, Sen. Jeff Flake of Arizona and Rep. Charlie Dent of Pennsylvania expressing dismay over an array of policy and personality questions — is almost certain to hurt the party’s political prospects in the long-term. This isn’t simply because Trump’s approval rating is in the low 40s and hasn’t been above 50 percent at any point during his presidency. It’s also because, from a policy perspective, this president has set America on a path that is bound to boomerang against it in the future.

Take the tariff issue that Corker raised. When Trump alienates Canada or Mexico or the G7 nations with his tough talk about tariffs, he doesn’t merely weaken some of America’s most important geopolitical alliances. He also endangers the foundations of the American economy.

“One of the great accomplishments of the post-World War II era was developing a more rational system of trade … that would help to prevent these kinds of tit-for-tat tariff retaliations,” Ed Gerwin of the Progressive Policy Institute told Salon in April. “I’m very concerned that what the administration is doing is attacking the very foundations of that post-war, rules-based trade regime … [which] has been hugely beneficial to the United States, despite some of the political rhetoric that you hear. I’m very concerned that this kind of non-strategic lashing out when it comes to tariffs is going to end up really harming the United States as much as anyone globally.”

ADVERTISEMENT

This is precisely the type of economic setback that Corker is ostensibly trying to avoid, and one might think that other Republican politicians — members of a party that has broadly supported free trade for the last 80 years — would be at least receptive to it. Instead, how did they react to Corker’s admonition?

On Wednesday, Trump loyalist Rep. Matt Gaetz, R-Fla., said it all: “I think that Sen. Corker is a little upset that he got passed over for secretary of state.”

“I think that Sen. Corker is a little upset that he got passed over for Secretary of State.”

@RepMattGaetz says about @SenBobCorker‘s comments that the Republican Party is not able to push back to President Trump. pic.twitter.com/nkGinNF3u7

ADVERTISEMENT

— MSNBC (@MSNBC) June 13, 2018

A similar problem could emerge in an area where Trump recently claimed a major achievement — namely, his Singapore summit with North Korean dictator Kim Jong-un. Although the president’s supporters are lauding that as a great foreign policy victory, it may not look that way for long. In April, Salon spoke to Jamie Fly, a foreign policy expert with the German Marshall Fund who served as foreign policy adviser to Florida Sen. Marco Rubio (yes, a Republican) during the 2016 presidential campaign. Fly’s comments foreshadowed precisely what happened in Singapore — namely, that the president essentially got nothing from North Korea despite making major concessions — as well as the possible consequences.

“The challenge for President Trump will be that, at the end of the day, even if he goes through with the summit, it’s very unlikely that the North Koreans will agree to make significant concessions related to their nuclear program,” Fly said. “Previous administrations have been through this cycle of escalation and negotiations in the past, and it hasn’t produced any significant change in the trajectory of North Korea’s weapons of mass destruction or its missile programs.”

If Trump “comes out of the summit without any significant offers by the North Koreans,” Fly continued, “I think he’s going to face a tough choice pretty quickly of whether he continues the pressure campaign through additional sanctions and economic pressure. But given his rhetoric in the past, he may have to face expedited consideration of various military options.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Even if economic or foreign policy catastrophes don’t ensue, the political arithmetic itself is still not favorable for Republican voters who are so enthusiastically tying their party’s future to the current president.

“Looking at things like the president’s approval rating … and the generic ballot being favorable to Democrats — how favorable is up to debate, it’s moved around a bit — I think that it’s definitely the case that a Republican who is critical of the president is risking their political health,” Skelley told Salon. “If you look at approval polls, Trump’s approval is somewhere between 80 and 85 percent among Republicans. … If you’re critical of a guy who’s that popular, you’re opening yourself up to a very easy attack by a primary opponent.”

But that fanatical loyalty comes with a cost, which may become clear in the 2018 midterms and again in the 2020 presidential election. “Even in a midterm election where most of the voters who show up are going to be partisans one way or the other, the president is so toxic to Democrats and a lot of independents that enforcing … strong loyalty to the president could lead to a number of Republican members losing,” Skelley said Salon. “It’s going to be very easy to tie them to the president, whether they want to be or not.”

He added, “There is a very hardcore, fervent element of the GOP base that is fully behind the president. That’s not the entirety of the GOP base, but it is a lot of it, and they end up enforcing loyalty to some degree. The politicians who are exhibiting disloyalty or who are at least critical of the president — most of them aren’t running for re-election. … It’s not hard to see why.”

Report typos and corrections to [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Trump considering withdraw from 68-year-old treaty with Japan: report

Published

on

President Donald Trump has been privately talking about withdrawing from the postwar defense treaty with Japan, according to three sources familiar with the matter.

Trump is telling confidants the treaty is unfair to the U.S. because it promises to help if Japan was ever attacked, but doesn't require Japan to come to America's defense, the sources told Bloomberg.

So far, the president hasn't taken any step toward pulling out of the treaty, which was signed in 1951, and administration officials insist that move would be highly unlikely.

Continue Reading

2020 Election

Rep. Ted Lieu: Impeachment is coming — and so is a Democratic president

Published

on

Donald Trump recently called “impeachment” a “dirty, filthy, disgusting word,” but his continued stonewalling of legitimate congressional oversight requests are moving more and more House Democrats to embrace that “filthy” concept. That was the very point made by Rep. Ted Lieu of California, a progressive Democrat who sits on the House Judiciary Committee during our recent conversation on “Salon Talks.” That committee would be the starting point for an actual impeachment inquiry of the president.

Continue Reading
 

2020 Election

New report targets 15 House Democrats who ‘deserve’ progressive primary challengers

Published

on

As progressive candidates continue to announce their intentions to oust corporate Democrats, a new report names 15 House Democrats to unseat in primary challenges.

Published Monday by the left-leaning group RootsAction, the new report is entitled Bad Blues: Some of the House Democrats Who Deserve to Be 'Primaried.'

The list, the report notes, "is by no means exhaustive—only illustrative."

"There may well be a Democratic member of Congress near you not included here who serves corporate interests more than majority interests, or has simply grown tired or complacent in the never-ending struggles for social, racial, and economic justice as well as environmental sanity and peace," the report notes. "Perhaps you live in a district where voters are ready to be inspired by a progressive primary candidate because the Democrat in Congress is not up to the job."

Continue Reading
 
 

Copyright © 2019 Raw Story Media, Inc. PO Box 21050, Washington, D.C. 20009 | Masthead | Privacy Policy | For corrections or concerns, please email [email protected]

 ENOUGH IS ENOUGH 

Trump endorses killing journalists, like Washington Post columnist Jamal Khashoggi. Online ad networks are now targeting sites that cover acts of violence against dissidents, LGBTQ people and people of color.

Learn how you can help.
close-link