Quantcast
Connect with us

Trump’s mental incapacity more obvious than ever post-Mueller: Yale psychiatrist

Published

on

- Commentary

This article was paid for by Raw Story subscribers. Not a subscriber? Try us and go ad-free for $1. Prefer to give a one-time tip? Click here.

On Thursday, the New York Times reported that members of Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s team claim Attorney General William Barr downplayed the conclusions of the Russia probe, telling the Times that the full report contained far more damning information than is evident in the memo.

President Trump and his associates celebrated the Barr statement as a full exoneration — even though the document explicitly stated that the probe had not exonerated Trump on obstruction of justice charges.

ADVERTISEMENT

Raw Story spoke with Dr. Bandy X. Lee about the wrap up of the years-long investigation and how the President and his critics have responded.

Lee is a psychiatrist at Yale School of Medicine who has taught at Yale Law School for over 15 years. She is an authority on violence prevention and President of the World Mental Health Coalition. Her New York Times bestseller, “The Dangerous Case of Donald Trump: 37 Psychiatrists and Mental Health Experts Assess a President,” has just been released as an expanded edition, alongside a major Washington conference on presidential fitness (dangerouscase.org).

Raw Story: Liberals are awaiting the release of the full Mueller report. But it seems increasingly likely that expectations of criminal wrongdoing — at least when it comes to Russia — aren’t really contained in the report. What’s a good way for people who are opposed to the Trump Presidency to respond?

Dr. Bandy X. Lee: Imagine an ocean liner. You need many components to be functioning so that you can get to where you need to go and not sink into the sea. You have to have an intact body, the internal mechanics or software has to be working right, and you have to have an able captain. Let’s say you inspect the body, and it is found to be intact. You still have to check the software and the captain.

A former White House ethics counsel told me there are “Three C’s” plaguing this presidency: collusion, corruption, and capacity. We don’t know if collusion is out, but criminal conspiracy seems to be—so far.

ADVERTISEMENT

Now, is Robert Mueller’s report—at least the reporting of the report—free of corruption? The attorney general appeared to be cherry-picking what he wished to highlight, attempting to redact not only classified and ongoing investigation information but plenty of other material. He resisted the demands of numerous experts, 83 percent of polled Americans, and an overwhelming 420-to-0 vote on a House resolution calling for release of the full report. Meanwhile, he used the delays to set a certain tone. All this is important, as we have been saying that the president’s psychology will be reflected in those he appoints: Jeff Sessions, as we saw, was pushed out for not being corrupt enough.

Raw Story: Does this also apply to his appointment of Supreme Court justices?

Dr. Bandy X. Lee: Absolutely. We need both preservation and innovation to survive, and so it is not about being liberal or conservative: it is about health versus disease. That Donald Trump would appoint a justice—Neil Gorsuch—who would argue that the death penalty need not be painless, defying American norms against cruel and unusual punishment, is unsurprising given the president’s propensity for cruelty. When he was about to nominate Brett Kavanaugh, a group of mental health professionals wrote to Congress that a president so apparently lacking in mental capacity would likely choose a justice who similarly lacks capacity, and indeed the confirmation was besieged with sexual assault allegations and thousands of law professors opposing him for lack of “judicial temperament.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Raw Story: So how does “capacity” relate to the Mueller report?

The report reveals many potential problems regarding mental capacity. For example, the absence of conspiracy with Russians does not eliminate past behavior, such as siding with Russian adversaries over our own intelligence agencies, or actively taking measures that increase Russia’s global standing and diminish ours. Absent a rational explanation, such as conspiracy, what was he doing? We have to consider incapacity as an explanation.

ADVERTISEMENT

So imagine you are having a heart attack. You don’t go to a dietician to work on your diet; you go directly to a heart doctor. In any other setting, you would take someone with the president’s symptoms of impulsivity, erratic thinking, and belligerent behavior for a mental health evaluation.

Currently, Mr. Trump’s rally speeches have been growing steadily less coherent, with rambling sentences, repetitions, and word-finding difficulties. A few weeks ago, there was the “Tim Apple” episode, and the other day he referred to Venezuela as a company, confused his father’s birthplace with his grandfather’s, and repeatedly pronounced “oranges” instead of “origins.” He even defensively said, “I’m very normal.”

Signs of mental incapacity were numerous even before recent declines, and we have not investigated them like collusion or corruption. Just a few include:
There’s impairment in his ability to stay grounded in reality: Mr. Trump’s notions of what is real seem driven by his own internal thoughts, emotions, and needs, such as when he declares a national emergency without evidence or dismisses official death tolls in Puerto Rico in the wake of Hurricane Maria.

ADVERTISEMENT

Impulsivity: from spontaneously mocking those he disapproves of, such as calling San Juan Mayor Carmen Cruz “crazed and incompetent,” to making announcements of international consequence via Twitter without consulting any advisors, Mr. Trump shows problems inhibiting his behavior on a daily basis.

He has an investment in getting his way rather than serving the public: Mr. Trump appears to be unable to let go of personal vendettas even after they are proven detrimental to the nation, such as when he brought up dismantling the Affordable Care Act without a plan for the millions of lives he would put at risk.

And he’s shown an inability to perceive his limits: Mr. Trump shows a severe inability to reflect realistically on the limits of his own knowledge, frequently declaring that he knows better than the experts.

Then there’s his attraction to conspiracy theories: Mr. Trump recurrently espouses and encourages conspiracy theories, such as that “the deep state” is out to get him or that “invading migrants” are threatening the country, claiming that these warrant violent uprising or closure of the borders.

ADVERTISEMENT

Raw Story: What can be done?

We know what to do and need not feel helpless. He is long overdue an evaluation, as even non-mental health professionals starkly revealed at the Washington conference. Mental health evaluations are very similar to legal investigations: even when a crime is obvious, you need an investigation to measure against existing standards and determine the precise indictment. Likewise, you need an evaluation to assess severity of symptoms and establish a definitive diagnosis. The course of treatment then follows.

I don’t believe we should declare a diagnosis without an examination, just as we shouldn’t indict someone without the proper legal process. One cannot use one’s own hired doctor to declare oneself “fit to serve,” as Mr. Trump has done, just as one cannot make one’s own hired lawyers prosecutor and judge. Capacity evaluations do not require consent, and the people, as the president’s employers, can demand one. If he is unwilling, he can resign. A pilot flying 300 passengers should have an intact mind; he is the pilot of 300 million citizens.

This article was paid for by Raw Story subscribers. Not a subscriber? Try us and go ad-free for $1. Prefer to give a one-time tip? Click here.


Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Trump spent 45 minutes talking with cast of right-wing play dramatizing ‘Deep State’ conspiracy theories: report

Published

on

The coronavirus emergency has given President Donald Trump one of the most daunting tests of his administration, with less than a year to go before he stands for re-election.

And yet in the midst of all the chaos, one thing the president found time to do on Thursday was meet with the cast of a bizarre right-wing play dramatizing the supposed "deep state" plot at the FBI to frame Trump in the Russia investigation.

According to The Daily Beast, Trump spent 45 minutes talking with the people behind "FBI Lovebirds: Undercovers," which focuses on the affair between FBI officials Peter Strzok and Lisa Page. The leading roles of Strzok and Page were played by Dean Cain, the former Superman actor, and Kristy Swanson, who played the starring role in the 1992 Buffy the Vampire Slayer movie.

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

All US Navy ships in the Pacific near countries with coronavirus ordered to self-quarantine for 14 days

Published

on

CNN National Security reporter Ryan Browne tweeted Thursday that the U.S. Navy has ordered all of its vessels in the Pacific that have been near countries with COVID-19, also known as the coronavirus, "to remain at sea for at least 14 days before pulling into another port in order to monitor sailors for any symptoms of the virus."

Health experts have said that the two-week period should give enough time for infected people to become aware that they are sick.

The highly-contagious disease has spread very quickly in South Korea and California after public exposure. The first person verified with "community-spread" transmission was identified just outside of Sacramento, California.

Continue Reading
 

Breaking Banner

‘Most wicked to ever represent Cleveland’: Jim Jordan ripped by hometown paper for covering up sex scandal

Published

on

President Trump likes to call his enemies 'sleaze bags" and Ohio GOP Rep. Jim Jordan a "warrior," but according to Cleveland Plain Dealer columnist Brent Larkin, Trump has it backward.

While Jordan may not seem like the worse politician to ever come out of Ohio, the "crimes" he's committed "don't involve felonies," according to Larkin. "They are crimes against America, crimes involving total disregard for the principles of democracy, trampling the truth on behalf of a corrupt president who revels in his inhumanity."

Watching Jordan question witnesses during the House impeachment inquiry particularly incensed Larkin, who writes that it was like watching a man who "spent his childhood gleefully ripping wings off flies."

Continue Reading
 
 
close-image