Trump ducked a question Alina Habba asked him on the stand — legal expert explains why

Trump ducked a question Alina Habba asked him on the stand — legal expert explains why
Donald Trump at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center. White House Photo by Tia Dufour.

Donald Trump was asked, among other things, by his lawyer Alina Habba, "Did you ever instruct anyone to hurt Ms. Carroll."

Trump didn't answer the question — something at least one legal analyst finds telling.

Instead, Trump said, "I just wanted to defend myself, my family and, frankly, this presidency."

Former Southern District of New York prosecutor Kristy Greenberg pointed out that Trump didn't say "yes or no."

"That's the delta," she explained. "He knows when he makes these statements about E. Jean Carroll, he knows the influence that he has over his followers. It's similar to Jan. 6th, when he's putting out various messages about, 'Come. Let's be wild.' The idea that he would have no idea the influence he would have and what would happen, I mean, that's why Jack Smith has charged him with exploiting those messages and exploiting the violence that he knew would come. It's very similar here."

She recalled that throughout the trial the jury has been told about rape and death threats that were sent to Carroll after she accused him of raping her — before and after Trump defamed her by denying it.

ALSO READ: Alina Habba is persona non grata at her Pennsylvania law school

Trump has already been found liable of sexual abuse and defamation. The ongoing trial relates to separate defamatory comments he made about the same attack. The jury is considering damages as the judge has already ruled him liable.

"He knows the effect of his words," said Greenberg. "He knows when he keeps saying she's a liar, that he's never met her and she's this terrible person, he knows what will follow, and in fact, intends it. That was the argument from E. Jean Carroll's attorneys at the opening. He intended for this violence to happen. Once it became clear that these tweets were happening, at no point did Donald Trump say, 'Hey, cut it out. Don't threaten her life. Don't threaten to rape this woman.'"

Like with Jan. 6, Trump never told his supporters not to go on the attack, she said.

"So, the parallels are similar, and the fact that he did not answer that question, did you ever instruct anyone to hurt her, yes or no, just tells you that he really doesn't want to disclaim his influence from his supporters, because they're actually doing what he wants them to do," Greenberg closed.

See her comments in the video below or at the link here.

This is the question from Alina Habba that Trump never answered www.youtube.com

For customer support contact support@rawstory.com. Report typos and corrections to corrections@rawstory.com.

In a Friday night ruling, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the Trump administration’s controversial policy to detain nearly all individuals facing deportation without bond, even if they have no criminal record and have lived in the U.S. for decades.

The decision, handed down by a divided three-judge panel, reverses three decades of federal precedent and contradicts thousands of lower court rulings nationwide, Politico reported.

“That prior Administrations decided to use less than their full enforcement authority … does not mean they lacked the authority to do more,” Judge Edith Jones, a Reagan appointee, wrote in the 2-1 majority opinion.

The ruling from the conservative New Orleans-based appeals court – a win for the MAGA administration – marks a stark break from the standard practice of allowing bond hearings for deportation cases, which has been upheld by the “vast majority” of judges across the country, according to the outlet.

“A POLITICO review of thousands of ICE detention cases found that at least 360 judges rejected the expanded detention strategy — in more than 3,000 cases — while just 27 backed it, in about 130 cases,” the report said.

Despite the Friday night ruling, legal experts say the case is likely to end up in the Supreme Court, where Trump’s hand-picked conservative justices hold a supermajority.

But according to Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, a senior fellow at the American Immigration Council, the ruling is "AWFUL news for due process."

"This decision will wipe out the availability of release through bond for tens of thousands of people detained in or transported to Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi by ICE," he wrote Friday. "This decision overturns 30 years of interpretation of a law passed in 1996."

THANKS FOR SUBSCRIBING! ALL ADS REMOVED!

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer didn’t waste any time firing back at President Donald Trump on Friday over claims that it was the New York Democrat who suggested renaming New York Penn Station and Washington Dulles International Airport after Trump.

“Chuck Schumer suggested that to me about changing the name of Penn Station to Trump Station,” the MAGA leader reportedly said while speaking to reporters on Air Force One.

But Schumer fiercely rejected that premise.

“Absolute lie,” Schumer wrote in a post on X. “He knows it. Everyone knows it. Only one man can restart the project and he can restart it with the snap of his fingers.”

The political back and forth came as reports emerged this week that Trump wants his name on both Dulles and Penn Station while threatening to withhold federal funding for a major transportation project connecting New York City and New Jersey. Schumer swiftly rejected the suggestion, according to media reports.

Schumer later targeted the president's since-deleted racist post depicting Barack and Michelle Obama as apes.

"Your dad has no obligation to post racist memes," he wrote in a reply post to Donald Trump Jr. "I wish someone would tell him that."

President Donald Trump used a lengthy Truth Social post on Friday to claim credit for a new commercial fishing proclamation – while issuing a plea to Maine and New England voters to remember him as the November midterms approach.

“Another BIG WIN for Maine, and all of New England!” Trump wrote. “Hard to believe you vote for Democrats who did this to you, but not for ‘TRUMP,’ who gets you out of this Environmental and Economic Malaise.”

He urged residents to “VOTE REPUBLICAN FROM NOW ON” and then went on to bash “the Radical Left” for what he called “Burdensome and Unnecessary Restrictions on EVERYTHING, including our Great American Fishermen.”

“In my First Term, I reversed the prohibitions placed on Commercial Fishing, but Joe Biden, or whoever was using the AUTOPEN, foolishly reinstated them. Since Day One, I have taken historic action to END these disastrous policies,” Trump claimed in his Friday post, adding that the proclamation he signed today “will revitalize our Fishing Industry, and STRENGTHEN our Booming Economy.”

He then congratulated “all of our Great Fishermen,” before making a direct plea to voters.

“Please remember I did this for you, against strong Democrat opposition, and VOTE REPUBLICAN IN THE MIDTERMS!” Maine voted Democratic in the last nine elections, according to 270towin.com, including in 2024 when Kamala Harris led Trump by 7%.

{{ post.roar_specific_data.api_data.analytics }}