One of the biggest surprises to emerge from the 2026 midterm elections may have been the apparent collapse of a political weapon President Donald Trump spent years cultivating, according to a new analysis in The Atlantic.
“MAGA may have been cannibalized in part by its own success,” legal analyst and staff writer Quinta Jurecic observed Wednesday, arguing that Trump’s election-denial movement is now “all but dead.”
The striking assessment comes nearly six years after the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol, as Trump’s claims of widespread election fraud, enthusiastically embraced by his supporters, appear to be fading among Republicans.
“The Big Lie might finally be ebbing as a defining force in American politics,” Jurecic wrote.
The shift became glaringly apparent, according to The Atlantic writer, following Republicans’ sweeping midterm defeats, when even prominent figures who previously promoted election conspiracy theories largely accepted the results.
Kate Starbird, a University of Washington professor who studies online misinformation, told The Atlantic that election conspiracy theories failed to gain nearly as much traction as they had in previous elections.
She described the activity surrounding election denialism immediately following the vote this month as “very low.”
“We’re seeing a few more activist journalists, people that work for hyperpartisan outlets, begin to play with this,” Starbird told The Atlantic, but not “more mainstream conservative political voices."
Republican politicians, meanwhile, appeared more interested in fighting among themselves rather than challenging the election results.
Jurecic suggested that Trump’s return to power may have inadvertently weakened the grassroots movement that once rallied around his claims.
“They were waiting for the Trump administration,” Starbird said, referring to MAGA activists who expected federal authorities to intervene by seizing ballots or otherwise challenging the election results.
Still, Starbird cautioned that election conspiracies have not disappeared and could resurface as Republicans grapple with their political future.
Report typos and corrections to corrections@rawstory.com.
For customer support contact support@rawstory.com.
Should Howard Lutnick be investigated for his ties to the Nvidia scandal?
VOTE NOW




