Download Our App
'Nothing-burger': Legal experts blow up new claims that judge is biased against Trump

'Nothing-burger': Legal experts blow up new claims that judge is biased against Trump

A new claim of judicial bias against Donald Trump in a criminal case arose and was smacked down on the same day on Wednesday.

A Breitbart reporter earlier in the day stated that Fulton County Superior Court Judge Scott McAfee is biased against Trump in the criminal case alleging a conspiracy to overturn the 2020 election in the state. Wendell Husebø reported that the judge "donated to Fani Willis," the prosecutor who is charging that case.

"The donation of $150, though small, appears to present a conflict of interest for Judge McAfee," he wrote. "Judges are supposed to be impartial and avoid any appearance of a conflict of interest. The judge donated to Willis in June 2020, while working for Joe Biden's DOJ."

ALSO READ: How Speaker Mike Johnson’s dream of bipartisan decency died in his hands

A conservative account responded to the report in the comments.

"So citizens should not donate to politians[sic] just in case they get appointed to the bench in the future?" the X user asked. "Is that the new rule?"

Georgia State law professor Anthony Michael Kreis took a moment to respond to the new allegation.

"This is non-news," he wrote Wednesday. "Sincerely, Anyone familiar with Georgia law and politics."

When asked to elaborate further, the professor told Raw Story that "exceptionally small donations do not constitute a conflict of interest. This stuff has been litigated extensively."

Anna Bower of Lawfare also claimed that "this is a nothingburger."

"Judge McAfee donated a small sum to Fani Willis's campaign in 2020—*before* he was appointed to the bench," Bower said. "And Georgia courts have held that nominal campaign contributions are an insufficient basis for judicial recusal. There's no conflict of interest."

She added:

"And, yes, Judge McAfee used to work under Fani Willis when he was an assistant prosecutor in Fulton County. (This was long before Willis ran for DA.) Again, not a sufficient basis for judicial recusal, as the Georgia Supreme Court has held."

Report typos and corrections to corrections@rawstory.com.

For customer support contact support@rawstory.com.

Top Stories Recommended For You

YOUR OPINION MATTERS

Do you think Donald Trump will cost Republicans the midterm elections?

VOTE NOW
Do you think Donald Trump will cost Republicans the midterm elections?