Warning of the possible "significant intimidating effect" of private recounts like the ongoing GOP-run audit of an Arizona county's 2020 election ballots, a senior official at the U.S. Justice Department's civil rights division on Thursday advised the Republican president of the southwestern state's Senate that such efforts may violate federal voting and civil rights laws.
"Such investigative efforts can have a significant intimidating effect on qualified voters that can deter them from seeking to vote in the future."
—Pamela S. Karlan, DOJ
In a letter (pdf) to Sen. Karen Fann (R-1), Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General Pamela S. Karlan wrote that plans by Cyber Ninjas—the online security firm hired by the Arizona Legislature to perform a hand recount of nearly 2.1 million Maricopa County ballots—to directly contact voters potentially constitutes intimidation.
"The information of which we are aware raises concerns regarding at least two issues of potential noncompliance with federal laws," the letter states.
"The first issue relates to a number of reports suggesting that the ballots, elections systems, and election materials that are the subject of the Maricopa County audit are no longer under the ultimate control of state and local elections officials, are not being adequately safeguarded by contractors at an insecure facility, and are at risk of being lost, stolen, altered, compromised, or destroyed," it continues.
"The second issue," the letter says, "relates to the Cyber Ninjas' statement of work for this audit," which "indicates that the contractor has been working 'with a number of individuals' to 'identify voter registrations that did not make sense, and then knock on doors to confirm if valid voters actually lived at the stated address.'"
"This description of the proposed work of the audit raises concerns regarding potential intimidation of voters," it warns. "Past experience with similar investigative efforts around the country has raised concerns that they can be directed at minority voters, which potentially can implicate the anti-intimidation prohibitions of the Voting Rights Act."
"Such investigative efforts can have a significant intimidating effect on qualified voters that can deter them from seeking to vote in the future," the letter concludes.
The Arizona Legislature is paying the Florida-based Cyber Ninjas—which has no elections experience and whose CEO Doug Logan is an advocate of the "Stop the Steal" movement claiming former President Donald Trump won the 2020 election—$150,000 to conduct the Maricopa County audit.
President Joe Biden won the county, which includes Phoenix and surrounding cities, by over 45,000 votes. In the race for the U.S. Senate, Democrat Mark Kelly defeated Republican Martha McSally by more than 80,000 votes in Maricopa County.
In addition to its CEO's affinity for Trump, Cyber Ninjas has also raised eyebrows and ire by allowing former Arizona GOP state lawmaker Anthony Kern, a rampant pro-Trump conspiracy theorist and participant in the deadly January 6 attack on the United States Capitol, to help conduct the audit.
The auditors—who have fallen far behind schedule—have investigated conspiracy theories during the course of their work, including one that 40,000 bamboo-laced Biden ballots were smuggled into the county from China.
The Justice Department letter follows an April request (pdf) by the Brennan Center for Justice—which said it is "very concerned that the auditors are engaged in ongoing and imminent violations of federal voting and election law"—for the DOJ to send federal monitors to oversee the Maricopa recount.
Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) was buried in ridicule on Thursday night after he all but admitted to Fox News personality Sean Hannity that the Republican Party is a full-fledged cult dedicated to Donald Trump.
With the GOP embroiled in a fight over the ousting of Rep. Liz Cheney (R-WY) from a leadership position due to her criticism of the former president, Graham took to Fox News to pledge his allegiance to Trump.
"Can we move forward without President Trump? The answer is no," Graham explained. "I've always liked Liz Cheney, but she's made the determination that the Republican Party can't grow with President Trump. I've determined we can't grow without him."
That led critics of Graham to pile on the longtime Republican senator for his slavish devotion.
You can see a sampling below:
🎶Tell me, how am I supposed to live without you? Now that I've been loving you so long How am I supposed to live wi… https://t.co/Y05LJkjepg— Eric Swalwell (@Eric Swalwell)1620352746.0
@Acyn Translation: "Russians hacked my email and yada yada yada, I'm owned."— Doc Gringo 🍀🇮🇪 (@Doc Gringo 🍀🇮🇪)1620356018.0
@Acyn Poor Lindsey Graham. A hopelessly sycophantic little crawler at every point. His honor and dignity were burie… https://t.co/ENaEHGps1T— Russell Drew (@Russell Drew)1620353843.0
@Acyn Here's a senior US senator arguing that his party CAN'T move forward without loyalty to their twice impeached… https://t.co/yB061W9SlN— Tony C 🇺🇸 (@Tony C 🇺🇸)1620377227.0
@Acyn I am so sick and tired of old white republican senators/congressmen who are terrified of turning their back o… https://t.co/3HKJm4PJNf— Patm1400 (@Patm1400)1620354289.0
@Acyn Lindsey Graham on 1/6: "Trump and I... we've had a hell of a journey. I hate it to end this way. Oh my god, I… https://t.co/K2qEM7XSt9— tim dewey (@tim dewey)1620357770.0
@Acyn The guy that lost the WH, Senate and the House in a mere 4 years flat.... is gonna help the party grow? Lindsey got jokes— Bala (@Bala)1620359746.0
@Acyn Didn’t take long for the GOP to go all in on fascism.— Shane (@Shane)1620352554.0
@Acyn Faced with this inexorable, juggernaut-like #sycophancy of the #GQP #RepubliQans towards Lord Pussygrabber Th… https://t.co/uIdI8Nxb5c— Kausik (@Kausik)1620375577.0
@Acyn Oh, Lindsey. The blackmail they have on you must be damning. Sad.— Sounds About Right 🌯 (@Sounds About Right 🌯)1620354351.0
@MerrillLynched @Acyn Until a bunch of trump supporters ambushed him at the airport with threats they will continue… https://t.co/OTtKeDQymy— Proud Hockey mom #BlackLivesMatter🇺🇸✊🏿✊🏾✊🏽 (@Proud Hockey mom #BlackLivesMatter🇺🇸✊🏿✊🏾✊🏽)1620359447.0
@Acyn Lost the House in 2018, lost the Senate and the Presidency in 2020! That's some remarkable growth!🤡— Cruz Thomas 🇺🇸 🌎 🐶🌄 (@Cruz Thomas 🇺🇸 🌎 🐶🌄)1620352028.0
@Acyn It can’t grow without a 74 year old grifter?— ScottDinBlueGeorgia💙🍑 (@ScottDinBlueGeorgia💙🍑)1620351908.0
@Acyn Has there ever been a party that stuck with a losing one term president, who also lost the house and the Sena… https://t.co/0zcf1HhZTY— Julian Turner (@Julian Turner)1620358206.0
@Acyn He lost you the senate, house, and presidency. He left office with a 38% approval rating. Thousands flocked t… https://t.co/fYH11n7c8K— Lakers SZN (37-28) (@Lakers SZN (37-28))1620355596.0
@Acyn Cool, the party will crumble.— tellthetruth (@tellthetruth)1620351756.0
Today's most prominent Republicans almost seem like cartoon villains: They are obvious in their schemes, exaggerated in their evil, sociopathic and antisocial as a group, and mean for the pure joy of it. Yet they somehow are still able to imagine themselves as being noble, misunderstood victims. Donald Trump, the acknowledged master of cartoon villainy, has become a role model of such behavior for the entire Republican Party.
Consider how Republicans reacted to President Biden's speech to Congress last week: It provided a national stage for their cartoon villainy.
During his speech, Joe Biden said that lead — and by implication other harmful materials — should be removed from the country's drinking water. This is hardly a controversial position and should have nothing to do with holding "liberal" or "conservative" political views. But Republicans as a group sat in silence, largely refusing to applaud such a basic and commonsensical proposal. Lead-poisoned water shortens lives and can cause developmental delays in children, as well as other emotional and psychological maladies. Environmental pollution is lethal: Scientists estimate that air pollution alone likely kills at least 200,000 people in the United States each year.
Biden also condemned gun violence and mass shootings. Biden also advocated for common sense gun laws — laws supported by a majority of Americans, including a large proportion of gun owners — to help ameliorate the country's plague of gun violence, which is estimated to have killed at least 38,000 Americans in 2019. Gun violence is estimated to cost the U.S. economy at least $229 billion each year. Republicans again sat in silence and refused to applaud.
Biden advocated expanding access to health care and other social safety net programs. In the midst of the coronavirus pandemic, such programs are essential to help save lives and mitigate the economic and social devastation caused by what we must hope is a once-in-a-generation event. In addition, expanding access to health care saves lives by helping to ameliorate risk factors such as pre-existing conditions that facilitate the spread and lethality of diseases such as COVID-19.
Republicans again — well, I hardly need to say it — displayed little or no enthusiasm.
In one of the greatest crimes in recent human history, the Trump regime and nearly the entire Republican Party engaged in acts of criminal negligence by refusing to properly respond to the coronavirus pandemic. Their actions quite plausibly led to the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Americans who might otherwise be alive today.
During his speech, Joe Biden also outlined an ambitious plan to combat childhood poverty, subsidize child care and early childhood education and provide two years of free college education. Such policies have long been advocated by a wide range of experts because they would stimulate the economy, improve wealth and income inequality across the color line, enhance life chances and improve intergenerational upward mobility. Moreover, such policies are likely to pay for themselves in the long run; they represent an investment in the country's future.
Again, the Republicans largely sat in sullen silence.
Biden also summarized the successes of the American Rescue Plan, saying that if current trends continue, childhood poverty will be reduced in America by almost 50 percent. The vast majority of Republicans did not applaud the prospect that fewer children will be forced to grow up poor.
Such behavior by elected members of Congress was immature and childish. But that should not be allowed to obscure a basic fact: Today's Republican Party may consist of cartoon villains, but that makes its policies no less dangerous to the American people and the world.
It is a fact, not an opinion, that policies advocated for and enacted by the Republican Party cause more illness, death, shortened lives and overall human suffering here in the United States than do Democratic policies — imperfect as those surely are.
One can easily demonstrate that today's Trumpian Republican Party uses pain as a type of political currency and an instrument of power.
Chris Hedges' most recent essay — published first at ScheerPost and then at Salon — details the broader relationship between sadism, politics and America's ailing culture and society:
Sadism now defines nearly every cultural, social and political experience in the United States. It is expressed in the greed of an oligarchic elite that has seen its wealth increase during the pandemic by $1.1 trillion while the country has suffered the sharpest rise in its poverty rate in more than 50 years. It is expressed in extrajudicial killings by police in cities such as Minneapolis. It is expressed in our complicity in Israel's wholesale killing of unarmed Palestinians, the humanitarian crisis engendered by the war in Yemen and our reigns of terror in Afghanistan, Iraq and Syria. It is expressed in the torture in our prisons and black sites. It is expressed in the separation of children from their undocumented parents, where they are held as if they were dogs in a kennel.
Later in the essay, Hedges returns to this theme:
The historian Johan Huizinga, writing about the twilight of the Middle Ages, argued that as things fall apart sadism is embraced as a way to cope with the hostility of an indifferent universe. No longer bound to a common purpose, a ruptured society retreats into the cult of the self. It celebrates, as do corporations on Wall Street or mass culture through reality television shows, the classic traits of psychopaths: superficial charm, grandiosity and self-importance; a need for constant stimulation; a penchant for lying, deception and manipulation; and the incapacity for remorse or guilt. Get what you can, as fast as you can, before someone else gets it. This is the state of nature, the "war of all against all" Thomas Hobbes saw as the consequence of social collapse, a world in which life becomes "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short." And this sadism, as Friedrich Nietzsche understood, fuels a perverted, sadistic pleasure.
Almost on cue, on Tuesday Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis announced he would suspend all local COVID-19 public health emergency orders, effectively turning Florida (like other red states) into an incubation chamber for the coronavirus.
Today's Republican Party is a cartoonish political organization. It is also a death cult and a dire threat to the public health of all Americans. That is a conundrum but not a contradiction. Its opponents must understand that both sides of the coin are equally dangerous.
Don't Sit on the Sidelines of History. Join Raw Story Investigates and Go Ad-Free. Support Honest Journalism.
$95 / year — Just $7.91/month
I want to Support More
$14.99 per month