Quantcast
Connect with us

People take health advice from celebrities like Gwyneth Paltrow — but science shows they really shouldn’t

Published

on

The author of the new book, “Is Gwyneth Paltrow Wrong About Everything?” said celebrity health advice is often so wrong that it prevents fans from becoming healthy or happy.

Timothy Caulfield researched and tested celebrity health and beauty tips and found that even when their advice is valid – they still manage to get things wrong, reported Vox.

“It’s incredible how much (Paltrow) is wrong about,” said the University of Alberta law professor. “Even when she is right about stuff — like telling people to eat more fruits and vegetables — there is always a bit of a tinge of wrongness. She’ll say, ‘It has to be organic,’ for example. She is still distracting us with these untrue details as opposed to just pushing the honest truth.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Caulfield said he never got to interview Paltrow, who dispenses advice through her lifestyle business Goop, but he suspects she actually believes most of the “absurd” claims her company pushes.

“You wonder, ‘How can this thinking person really believe this?’” he said. “She does seem like she’s very bright, and I think she does believe this stuff. I think she’s quite genuine.”

He said celebrities like Paltrow are largely responsible for promoting bogus detoxification and cleansing programs, which are not supported by scientific evidence.

“Our cognitive biases play a big role,” Caulfield said. “Take someone like Paltrow. She’s a beautiful woman. When she’s endorsing something, it looks like it works, and her advice is available to us — it’s just more prominent than other people’s advice. It also confirms that desire for us to have some simple answer to difficult health questions.”

He said celebrities have filled a knowledge gap that’s created as trust in science erodes and social media become more influential.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I don’t think people consciously say, ‘Let celebrities step in,’” Caulfield said. “But they have. Their voice is louder and seems more credible, and other counterweights in society, for whatever reason, seem to have less credibility.”

However, he sees reasons to be hopeful that science may still prevail.

“We’ve seen the reaction to Dr. Oz (who has been criticized for promoting bogus claims on his TV show),” Caulfield said. “Even the reaction to the anti-vaccine story over the past year is very different than I’ve seen play out in other years. We’re starting to see a bit of a pushback. But what’s also needed: The scientific community has to get engaged, use celebrity culture as a Trojan horse to talk about what science says in these areas, and step in.”

ADVERTISEMENT


Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Trump White House shamelessly uses Fiona Hill’s testimony to paint Democrats as Russian puppets

Published

on

Even though former Trump National Security Council official Fiona Hill angrily denounced President Donald Trump and his allies for spreading Russian conspiracy theories during her impeachment inquiry testimony, the Trump White House is trying to turn her statements against House Democrats.

During her testimony, Hill said that Russia's actions during the 2016 presidential election are still being felt to this day, and they've all been negative for the United States.

"Our nation is being torn apart," she said. "Truth is questioned. Our highly professional and expert career foreign service is being undermined... The Russian government's goal is to weaken our country -- to diminish America's global role and to neutralize a perceived U.S. threat to Russian interests."

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

GOP ignoring Sondland because they already know Trump is guilty and ‘just don’t care’: conservative columnist

Published

on

In a column for the Bulwark, the founder and editor of the conservative website took at hard slap at both Donald Trump's most avid defenders in Congress and their fellow Republicans who have remained silent after E.U. Ambassador Gordon Sondland testified in no uncertain terms that the president was engaged in bribery in his dealings with Ukraine's government.

According to Charlie Sykes, "Yes, there was a quid pro quo. The president demanded it. Everybody knew about it. There was no secret. But we knew all that didn’t we?"

Continue Reading
 

Breaking Banner

Ex-Fox News executive caught running a disinformation and fake news farm — using writers from Macedonia

Published

on

A New York Times expose revealed that Fox News paid writers in Macedonia to create click-bait that prompt Americans to fight more about issues.

According to the piece, both the left and right websites created by an international content farm to inflame people enough to click and share content. Conservative Edition News and Liberal Edition News intentionally writes stories with the purpose to infuriate each side for the purpose of generating hate-clicks, response articles and more. Headlines like "Austin sex-ed curriculum teaches kids how to obtain an abortion" and "HuffPost writer considers Christianity 'dangerous'" give right-wing audiences fodder for anger to lash out at their counterparts.

Continue Reading
 
 

Happy Holidays!

As a special thank you from all of us at Raw, we're offering Raw Story ad-free for 15% off - just $2 per week. Now 'til Dec. 31st.
Offer Expires In:
close-link