Quantcast
Connect with us

Donald Trump’s latest conspiracy theory is impossible to follow — and that’s the point

Published

on

In his endless quest to find ways to discredit Robert Mueller’s investigation of ties between his campaign and Russian crimes meant to influence the election, Donald Trump this week really dug his heels into a conspiracy theory centered around Carter Page, a disquietingly strange former campaign aide of Trump’s who has extensive and unsavory connections to the Kremlin.

ADVERTISEMENT

For months, Trump and his supporters have been circulating a confusing conspiracy theory about a FISA warrant issued against Page, which is somehow evidence that the Trump campaign was unfairly victimized by a conspiracy between Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton . For days now, Trump has been escalating his efforts to seed this conspiracy theory, spraying out angry, incoherent tweets squawking about the “Fake Dirty Dossier,” the “Obama Gang” and the “discredited Mueller Witch Hunt,” all in response to the New York Times publication of Justice Department documents regarding Page. Trump spokespeople have fanned out over cable news to seed the idea that somehow Page getting surveilled somehow means Trump is the victim of a frame-up.

That Trump, who openly and publicly colluded with Vladimir Putin to deny Russia’s criminal hacking during a recent press conference, would want to direct attention away from the real crimes against the Clinton campaign and toward the fake crimes against the Trump campaign is unsurprising. But I must admit I found myself a little surprised to see so much energy going towards this conspiracy theory that’s grown up around the FBI’s surveillance of Page. Not because Trump is lying — which Trump clearly is doing and which he does about everything all the time — but because this particular conspiracy theory is so complex and confusing that it’s hard to imagine that Trump’s supporters are able to follow along.

But in reality, it may be that the confusing nature of the Page conspiracy theory is the point, and that it is actually helping Trump’s efforts to discredit the Mueller investigation.

The real story of Page is clear enough. He worked for the Trump campaign, albeit briefly and at some distance from the candidate. Thanks to evidence collected from multiple sources, the FBI, as clearly stated in its FISA warrant request, came to believes Page was “the subject of targeted recruitment by the Russian government” and that he had been “collaborating and conspiring with the Russian government.”

In contrast, the Trumpian conspiracy theory is hard to follow. As far as I can tell, Trump seems to be claiming that the FBI, under Obama and in conspiracy with Clinton, falsified information against Page to get this warrant. And the “evidence” for this is the existence of a dossier compiled by private intelligence researcher Christopher Steele, which was part, but certainly not all, of the FBI’s case. Trump claims the Steele dossier is somehow discredited because the Clinton campaign, at one point, was financing Steele’s work. (Initially, he had been funded by a Republican hostile to Trump.) If Page is so innocent, this complex conspiracy to surveil him was supposed to make a difference isn’t really explained, though Trump tries to distract from that question by posturing dramatically in faux outrage over all this.

ADVERTISEMENT

Odds are the typical Fox News viewer, when asked to explain who Page is and why his story somehow proves Trump is innocent, would have no idea what the hell is supposed to be going on and certainly not why any of this proves Trump’s innocence. But that’s probably the point. The complex nature of the Page conspiracy theory works to shield the claims being made from critical inquiry. By dumping a bunch of hard-to-follow noise about Page and the Russians and FISA warrants and dossiers and Obama and Steele, Trump and is propaganda administrators will scare most people away from even trying to figure out what the hell is going on.

And because people aren’t looking too closely, they won’t be able to see the huge holes in Trump’s story, much less take the time to understand the various lies propping it up. Instead, most people will see this complex knot of accusations and counter-accusations about Trump and the Russians and just decide to believe whoever they want to believe rather than figuring it out.

It’s human nature, when confronted with a complex subject that’s hard to wrap your mind around, for people simply to take on faith what people they already trust or like think about it. Most people don’t understand complex scientific theories, for instance, so they look instead to trusted authorities to assure them that yes, we know how chemotherapy works or why airplanes fly, so you don’t have to know the exact mathematics.

ADVERTISEMENT

But that same take-it-on-faith attitude can be easily exploited by bad actors. The climate-change “controversy” is a good example. Few people really understand the science behind it, so instead they put their trust in authority figures. Climate-change denialists take advantage of that fact, presenting their “criticisms” of the science as if they were on equal footing with the actual science, knowing that most people are going to decide not based on logical analysis of evidence they hardly understand, but a gut sense of who in the debate they trust more.

So it benefits the Trump administration to make the Russian collusion story, which is already confusing and complex enough, even more confusing. Every opportunity to present more twists and turns and characters into the narrative — such as making an issue out of FBI agent Peter Strzok’s private text messages (which are actually irrelevant) or floating elaborate conspiracy theories about Carter Page — means that many more Americans decide to tune out of the Russia story.

ADVERTISEMENT

This is likely why White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders announced, with great fanfare, a list of names of previous officials whose security clearance Trump plans to revoke. The move is being interpreted as petty, childish vengeance on these people for speaking out against Trump, and it’s certainly that. But it also means that the cast of characters of this particular drama got even longer and more confusing. Which means more Americans will give up trying to follow the story, and instead put their faith in authority figures to handle that for them.

For most Republicans, as bizarre as this may seem, that means choosing to put their faith in Donald Trump, rather than trying to figure out what the hell is really going on.

 


Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

George Zimmerman announces lawsuit against Pete Buttigieg and Elizabeth Warren for $265 million

Published

on

The man who killed Trayvon Martin was never held accountable for his crime, but he's spent the years since his acquittal blaming other people for persistent problems in his life. The latest news on George Zimmerman is that he's suing presidential candidates Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) and Mayor Pete Buttigieg.

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

America’s millionaires just stopped paying into Social Security for the rest of 2020

Published

on

On Wednesday, not even two full months into 2020, millionaires will stop paying into Social Security for the year due to the program's payroll tax cap.

The cap limits annual wages subject to the Social Security payroll tax to the first $137,700. Sarah Rawlins, program associate at the Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR), wrote Tuesday that the cap means "someone who makes $1,000,000 per year stops paying into the program on February 19, 2020."

"That makes a millionaire's effective tax rate well below the 6.2% of income that most Americans pay," Rawlins noted. "Instead, it is less than 1% of a millionaire's income. The Social Security tax is only levied on wages, excluding income from other sources like capital gains, meaning those with wages over the cap likely have an effective tax rate even lower than this estimate."

Continue Reading
 

Breaking Banner

DOJ puts out bizarre late-night statement: AG Bill Barr ‘has no plans to resign’

Published

on

The Department of Justice put out a statement Tuesday evening denying that Attorney General Bill Barr would be resigning from office.

Kerri Kupec, the director of communications and public affairs at DOJ, issued the statement at 10:28 p.m. in Washington, DC.

"Addressing Beltway rumors: The Attorney General has no plans to resign," Kupec announced.

The denial came after a Washington Post report that Barr was considering quitting if Trump continues to tweet about active investigations.

Continue Reading
 
 
close-image