Tourists visiting Washington, DC, may be gazing at the barren spot where the East Wing used to exist longer than Donald Trump might like as his plans for a massive ballroom appear to be headed to court.
According to the Washington Post, three Trump loyalists he installed on the National Capital Planning Commission lack the expertise legally required for the position — a vulnerability that could torpedo the entire project or, at minimum, delay it indefinitely.
Federal law explicitly mandates that planning commission appointees possess "experience in city or regional planning." Historically, these seats have gone to credentialed professionals in planning, architecture, or historic preservation. Trump's three picks — White House staff secretary Will Scharf, White House deputy chief of staff James Blair, and OMB associate director Stuart Levenbach — have none of that background, according to watchdog groups, former commissioners, and congressional Democrats.
The appointments underscore a troubling pattern across Trump's second term: filling expert positions with political operatives. The Commission of Fine Arts—the other panel reviewing the ballroom proposal — has been similarly stacked with Trump loyalists, including 26-year-old Chamberlain Harris, his executive assistant whose desk sits steps from the Oval Office.
When Congress established the arts commission 116 years ago, it directed presidents to appoint "well-qualified judges of the fine arts."
Whether these expertise requirements carry legal weight remains contested. Since taking office, Trump's Justice Department has argued in multiple court filings that the Constitution grants presidents absolute authority to appoint federal officers with no restrictions.
His opponents reject that interpretation, arguing that replacing credentialed experts with political cronies delegitimizes federal decisions and exposes them to legal challenge. In this case, the tainted appointments could invalidate any vote on the ballroom project.
"Those appointments were not just a crude political power play. They were unlawful, and they destroy the credibility of the vote on this project if those individuals vote for it," Jon Golinger, democracy advocate with Public Citizen, told the commissioners last week.
A legal analysis by Cultural Heritage Partners—a firm suing the administration over plans to paint the Eisenhower Executive Office Building white—compared appointee qualifications across three administrations. The findings were damning: Biden's picks included a city planner, architectural historian, and land-use lawyer with county planning board experience. Trump's second-term slate represented a radical departure from that standard.
"Trump's second-term appointments represent a major shift," the analysis concluded.
You can read more here.
